Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumRelationships Between Sections and Paragraphs

The following passage is adapted from an essay on the history of cartography.

Paragraph 1
Historically, early cartography was less concerned with physical accuracy than with ideological expression. Medieval mappa mundi, for instance, prioritized theological significance over geographical precision, placing Jerusalem at the center of the world and sizing lands according to their spiritual importance. These maps served as narrative landscapes, guiding the viewer's moral journey rather than their physical travels. Consequently, early mapmakers freely distorted coastlines and distances to accommodate illustrations of biblical events and mythical creatures, reflecting a worldview where symbolic meaning trumped empirical fact.

Paragraph 2
However, the fifteenth-century translation of Ptolemy's Geography into Latin catalyzed a fundamental shift in European mapmaking. Ptolemy introduced a grid system of longitude and latitude based on astronomical observations, providing a mathematical framework that demanded geometric consistency. Mapmakers began to discard religious allegory in favor of cartographic projection, treating the map not as a canvas for moral storytelling but as a precise instrument for navigation. This transition from symbolic representations to mathematical coordinates marked the birth of modern cartography, transforming how humanity visualized and traversed the globe.

Which of the following best describes the relationship between the description of medieval mapmaking in Paragraph 1 and the discussion of fifteenth-century cartography in Paragraph 2?

  1. Paragraph 2 details a transition toward mathematical precision that departed from the symbolic conventions described in Paragraph 1.Answer
  2. B
    Paragraph 2 identifies specific geographical errors in medieval maps and explains how Ptolemy corrected their calculations.
  3. C
    Paragraph 2 provides empirical evidence to validate the spiritual and theological worldview outlined in Paragraph 1.
  4. D
    Paragraph 2 traces the gradual development of the narrative and artistic techniques mentioned in Paragraph 1.

Answer

Paragraph 2 details a transition toward mathematical precision that departed from the symbolic conventions described in Paragraph 1.
The correct answer is correct because Paragraph 1 characterizes medieval mapmaking as prioritizing theological narrative over geographical accuracy, while Paragraph 2 introduces Ptolemy's coordinate grid system as a catalyst for a fundamental shift toward mathematical consistency and empirical navigation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the main focus of Paragraph 1.
Paragraph 1 describes early, medieval mapmaking as being focused on symbolic, theological narrative, where geographical accuracy was secondary to ideological representation.
This establishes the initial state of cartography described in the passage.
2
Analyze the main focus of Paragraph 2.
Paragraph 2 describes the transition to modern cartography, driven by Ptolemy's mathematical grid system, which prioritized geometric consistency and navigation over religious allegory.
This establishes the subsequent state and shift described in the passage.
3
Determine the relationship between the two paragraphs.
The relationship is one of contrast and shift, moving from the symbolic conventions of Paragraph 1 to the mathematical precision of Paragraph 2.
Connecting the two paragraphs reveals the structural development of the passage.

Key Concept

Identifying structural transitions and relationships between paragraphs in a passage.
Rate this question

Topics

Relationships Between Sections and Paragraphs

More questions from this topic