Question

Difficulty: MediumDistinguishing Claims from Evidence

For decades, Mesoamerican archaeologists debated the primary function of the expansive, open plazas located at the center of Classic Maya city-states. Early research frequently characterized these spaces as grandiose stages designed almost exclusively for elite religious performances and political propaganda. However, recent excavations at smaller, peripheral sites suggest that plazas served a far more democratic and economic purpose: facilitating daily marketplace exchange. At the site of Xunantunich, soil chemistry analyses revealed high concentrations of phosphorus—a chemical signature typically left behind by decomposed organic matter like food scraps—arranged in neat, grid-like patterns across the main plaza floor. Additionally, archaeologists uncovered micro-artifacts, such as tiny obsidian flakes and pottery sherds, clustered in ways that mirror modern open-air markets. These findings indicate that while elite rituals certainly occurred on the surrounding temples, the plaza floor itself was a bustling hub of commerce for commoners. Thus, the traditional view of the Maya plaza as a purely ceremonial space must be revised to recognize its role in daily economic life.

Which of the following statements from the passage represents a claim made by the author rather than a piece of supporting evidence?

  1. A
    Soil chemistry analyses at the Xunantunich site revealed high concentrations of phosphorus in grid-like patterns.
  2. B
    Clusters of tiny obsidian flakes and pottery fragments were discovered on the plaza floor.
  3. The central plazas of Classic Maya city-states served a daily economic function by hosting marketplace exchanges.Answer
  4. D
    Decomposed food scraps and organic matter left behind specific chemical signatures on the plaza floor.

Answer

The statement asserting that the central plazas of Classic Maya city-states served a daily economic function by hosting marketplace exchanges represents a claim rather than evidence.
The correct answer is the statement that the central plazas of Classic Maya city-states served a daily economic function by hosting marketplace exchanges. This statement is a claim (an assertion that requires proof and represents the author's primary argument). The passage uses the physical findings at Xunantunich to support this claim.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's primary argument or conclusion in the passage.
The author argues that traditional views of the Maya plaza must be revised because these spaces served an economic purpose (hosting marketplaces).
Locating the central thesis helps distinguish the overarching claims from the specific facts used to build the argument.
2
Analyze the remaining statements to determine if they represent data, observations, or physical findings.
Statements regarding phosphorus concentrations, obsidian flakes, and decomposing organic matter are physical findings (data) gathered during excavations.
Physical findings and scientific observations serve as evidence that supports the broader assertion about marketplace activity.
3
Match the option that represents a broad assertion (claim) rather than a factual observation (evidence).
The statement that plazas functioned as marketplace exchanges is a claim, while the other statements are the specific pieces of evidence supporting it.
A claim is an assertion that requires proof, whereas evidence consists of the facts and data used to prove that assertion.

Key Concept

Distinguishing between an author's argumentative claims (assertions requiring proof) and the supporting evidence (factual data, observations, or findings) used to validate those claims.
Rate this question