Question

Difficulty: MediumDetermining Control Groups and Baseline Conditions

Researchers conducted an experiment to measure the rate of crude engine oil degradation by the soil bacterium *Pseudomonas putida* in the presence of varying concentrations of a chemical surfactant (Surfactant X). Five culture flasks were prepared with identical volumes (100 mL100\text{ mL}) of sterile mineral salts growth medium and equal amounts (2.0 g2.0\text{ g}) of crude oil:

- Flask 1: Growth medium + engine oil (no bacteria, no Surfactant X)
- Flask 2: Growth medium + engine oil + 1.0 mL1.0\text{ mL} bacterial culture (no Surfactant X)
- Flask 3: Growth medium + engine oil + 1.0 mL1.0\text{ mL} bacterial culture + 0.5 g0.5\text{ g} Surfactant X
- Flask 4: Growth medium + engine oil + 1.0 mL1.0\text{ mL} bacterial culture + 1.0 g1.0\text{ g} Surfactant X
- Flask 5: Growth medium + engine oil + 1.0 mL1.0\text{ mL} bacterial culture + 2.0 g2.0\text{ g} Surfactant X

All flasks were incubated at 30C30^\circ\text{C} for 14 days, after which the total percentage of degraded oil was measured.

Which flask was included to establish the baseline rate of non-biological (abiotic) oil breakdown in the absence of bacterial activity?

  1. Flask 1Answer
  2. B
    Flask 2
  3. C
    Flask 3
  4. D
    Flask 5

Answer

Flask 1
Flask 1 establishes the baseline for abiotic oil breakdown because it omits the biological agent (bacterial culture) as well as the chemical treatment (surfactant). Comparing degradation in active bacterial flasks to Flask 1 ensures that any observed oil loss is attributed to bacterial action rather than spontaneous non-biological weathering.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the variable whose baseline effect needs to be isolated.
The target baseline is non-biological (abiotic) oil breakdown, which requires removing all biological activity (bacterial culture).
Control groups isolate specific variables by withholding the key independent variable or treatment.
2
Examine the composition of each flask to find the one omitting bacterial culture.
Flask 1 contains only growth medium and engine oil, with no bacterial culture or surfactant added.
Omitting bacteria ensures any measured degradation in this flask is solely due to non-biological processes.
3
Confirm that Flask 1 serves as the abiotic negative control.
Flask 1 establishes the reference rate of non-biological degradation against which biological rates in Flasks 2–5 can be compared.
Subtracting abiotic losses observed in Flask 1 from total losses in bacterial flasks isolates true biodegradation.

Key Concept

Identifying Negative Control Groups for Abiotic Baseline Conditions
Rate this question