Question

Difficulty: Very hardAnalogous Relationships

In many sub-Arctic forest ecosystems, the colonization and growth of white spruce trees are initially made possible by the presence of alder shrubs, which enrich the nutrient-poor soil with nitrogen. As the spruce trees grow taller and develop dense canopies, however, they begin to block essential sunlight from reaching the forest floor, eventually shading out and eliminating the lower-lying alders. Without the alders to continually replenish the soil's nitrogen levels, the nutrient quality of the ground gradually deteriorates over subsequent decades. Consequently, the spruce forest's own long-term growth rate slows down significantly, leaving the weakened trees vulnerable to devastating pest infestations and preventing the forest from achieving a stable, permanent climax state.

The relationship between the white spruce trees and the alder shrubs, as described in the passage, is most analogous to which of the following scenarios?

  1. A
    A chemical plant releases warm wastewater into a nearby river, which accelerates the growth of an invasive algae species that eventually blocks sunlight, killing native aquatic plants.
  2. B
    A nation's government subsidizes a new solar power industry to reduce reliance on fossil fuels, but the high taxes required for the subsidy eventually bankrupt the solar companies, forcing the government to return to fossil fuels.
  3. An online retailer relies on a local courier service to build its customer base by offering cheap, rapid deliveries. As the retailer's sales volume surges, its demanding delivery schedules overwhelm the courier, driving it out of business. Lacking the courier's specialized local network, the retailer's delivery times plummet, causing customers to abandon the retailer for competitors.Answer
  4. D
    A species of vine uses a sturdy oak tree for physical support to climb toward the forest canopy, gaining access to sunlight without affecting the tree's growth.

Answer

The scenario describing an online retailer whose growth overwhelms the local courier service it relies upon, ultimately causing the retailer's own decline.
The correct option describes a relationship with the identical structural dynamic as the passage. In the passage, one entity (the alders) facilitates the growth of a second entity (the spruce trees). The growth of the second entity then directly causes the elimination of the first entity (by blocking sunlight). Finally, the loss of the first entity causes the second entity to suffer (due to nutrient depletion). Similarly, the courier service facilitates the growth of the retailer; the retailer's growth drives the courier out of business; and the lack of the courier causes the retailer to fail.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the relationship and sequence of events between the white spruce trees and the alder shrubs in the passage.
The alders enrich the soil, enabling the spruce trees to grow. As the spruce trees grow, they block sunlight and eliminate the alders. Without the alders, the soil deteriorates, stunting the spruce trees' own growth.
To identify the abstract logical structure of the biological interaction: one entity enables another, the enabled entity's growth destroys the helper, and the loss of the helper subsequently harms the enabled entity.
2
Evaluate the options to find a scenario that shares this identical three-part feedback loop, ignoring the surface-level details.
The option about the online retailer fits this pattern: the courier service (helper) enables the retailer's growth; the retailer's growth drives the courier out of business; the absence of the courier causes the retailer to lose customers and decline.
To determine which relationship is structurally parallel (analogous) to the one in the passage.

Key Concept

Analogous Relationships
Estimated Time:3m 0s
Rate this question