Question

Difficulty: MediumRelationships Between Sections and Paragraphs

The passage is adapted from an article about ancient engineering.

Paragraph 1
Modern concrete, while structurally formidable, is notorious for its vulnerability to environmental degradation, often requiring extensive maintenance within a few decades. In contrast, structures built with Roman concrete, such as the Pantheon and ancient harbor barriers, have survived for millennia despite being subjected to seismic activity and corrosive saltwater. For years, material scientists struggled to explain the exceptional durability of this ancient substance, attributing it vaguely to volcanic ash or proprietary mixing techniques that had been lost to history.

Paragraph 2
Recent chemical analyses of Roman concrete samples have resolved this mystery, revealing that the key lies in a process called "hot mixing." Researchers discovered tiny, millimeter-scale white mineral chunks, known as "lime clasts," throughout the ancient mortar. Previously dismissed as mere evidence of poor mixing or low-quality raw materials, these clasts are actually active self-healing agents. When cracks form in the concrete, rainwater seeping into the fractures dissolves the calcium-rich clasts, recrystallizing the minerals into the cracks and sealing them before significant structural failure can occur.

Which of the following best describes the relationship between Paragraph 2 and Paragraph 1?

  1. A
    Paragraph 2 refutes a common misconception about modern concrete that was established in Paragraph 1.
  2. Paragraph 2 explains the chemical mechanism responsible for a durable material introduced in Paragraph 1.Answer
  3. C
    Paragraph 2 provides a chronological history of the scientific research that led to the hypothesis proposed in Paragraph 1.
  4. D
    Paragraph 2 outlines a series of practical solutions to the structural failures detailed in Paragraph 1.

Answer

Paragraph 2 explains the chemical mechanism responsible for a durable material introduced in Paragraph 1.
The correct answer is the option stating that Paragraph 2 explains the chemical mechanism responsible for a durable material introduced in Paragraph 1. Paragraph 1 introduces Roman concrete and notes that its durability has been an unexplained mystery for years. Paragraph 2 resolves this mystery by detailing the chemical self-healing process driven by lime clasts during hot mixing.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the main function of Paragraph 1.
Paragraph 1 introduces the contrast between modern concrete (prone to degradation) and Roman concrete (highly durable over millennia), noting that scientists have long struggled to explain this mystery.
Establishing the purpose of the first section helps determine how the subsequent section builds upon or changes the discussion.
2
Analyze the main function of Paragraph 2.
Paragraph 2 presents the resolution to the mystery introduced in Paragraph 1, specifically detailing how the 'hot mixing' process and 'lime clasts' work chemically to self-heal fractures.
Understanding the second paragraph's focus allows us to define its logical and structural connection to the first paragraph.
3
Evaluate the relationship between the two paragraphs.
The second paragraph provides the scientific explanation (the chemical self-healing mechanism of lime clasts) for the phenomenon introduced in the first paragraph (the unexplained durability of Roman concrete).
Matching this relationship to the choices leads to the correct option.

Key Concept

Analyzing paragraph relationships and rhetorical transitions
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question