Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumNarrative Distance and Point of View

Read the passage below:

The carriage had not yet reached the gates of Oakridge when Clara decided she would hate it. She did not look at the manicured lawns, which she knew to be maintained by the sweat of half-compensated tenants, nor at the grand stone portico that loomed like a grey monolith against the rainy sky. Instead, she stared at her own gloved fingers, counting the tiny, uneven stitches in the leather. To Clara, each stitch was a testament to the family's decline, a cheap repair hiding under the guise of gentility. The narrator, observing her from a distance that grew colder as the carriage climbed the hill, noted only that the gloves were of the finest French kidskin, purchased during a more prosperous spring, and that Clara's disdain was an armor she wore to prevent the world from seeing how desperately she wished to be welcomed inside.

Which of the following best describes the effect of the shift in narrative distance in the passage?

  1. reveal the contrast between Clara's internal defensiveness and the reality of her social vulnerabilityAnswer
  2. B
    confirm that the family's absolute financial ruin has forced Clara to wear poorly repaired clothing
  3. C
    express the author's moral condemnation of the wealthy estate owners of Oakridge
  4. D
    detail the chronological sequence of Clara's journey from her family home to the gates of Oakridge
  5. E
    signal a transition from a first-person participant narrator to an omniscient narrator

Answer

The shift in narrative distance serves to reveal the contrast between Clara's internal defensiveness and the reality of her social vulnerability.
The correct answer shows how the narrator shifts from a close, subjective third-person limited perspective to a more detached, objective distance. This shift exposes the contradiction between Clara's internal defensive posture (treating her gloves as a sign of ruin and showing disdain) and her actual vulnerability (her underlying desire to be welcomed).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the point of view and narrative voice in the first half of the passage.
The narrative begins in the third person but maintains a very close narrative distance to Clara, aligning with her thoughts, perceptions, and subjective judgments about the lawns and her gloves.
Understanding the initial narrative distance sets a baseline for tracking shifts in perspective.
2
Locate the shift in narrative distance and analyze the narrator's commentary in the second half of the passage.
The narrator explicitly steps back to provide objective information about the gloves (finest French kidskin) and her psychological motivation (using disdain as protective armor).
Recognizing the shift in distance allows the reader to contrast Clara's subjective feelings with the narrator's objective assessment.
3
Determine the thematic effect of this narrative shift.
The shift highlights the gap between Clara's internal insecurity (her need for armor) and her outward defensiveness, revealing her social vulnerability.
The correct choice must explain how the technique of changing narrative distance functions to develop the character's presentation.

Key Concept

Narrative Distance and Point of View
Rate this question

Topics

Narrative Distance and Point of View

More questions from this topic