Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumMetaphorical Comparisons and Allusions

The following passage is from a contemporary story about a city planner named Irene.

In the cramped office of the municipal planning department, Irene worked between the towering stack of pending zoning violations on her left and the ledger of developers' campaign contributions on her right. Every decision she made was a meticulous negotiation, a charting of a course through a strait so narrow that she felt the paint scraping off her sides. To lean too far toward regulatory zeal was to risk the wrath of the city council; to bend too far toward the developers was to invite the ruin of the local wetlands. In the quiet of the evening, she saw her career as a perilous navigation between Scylla and Charybdis, where one misstep would either tear her professional integrity to pieces or drown her in political ruin.

Which of the following best describes the function of the allusion to Scylla and Charybdis in the passage?

  1. A
    describe the actual geographical hazards of the coastal wetlands surrounding the municipal building
  2. B
    assert the author's personal moral condemnation of the developers' corrupt influence on municipal governance
  3. illustrate the dual, equally destructive forces between which Irene must navigate to maintain her positionAnswer
  4. D
    imply that Irene is planning a literal sea voyage to escape the moral compromises of her bureaucratic work
  5. E
    provide a chronological summary of the specific zoning files Irene must resolve before her evening shift ends

Answer

The option stating that the allusion illustrates the dual, equally destructive forces between which Irene must navigate to maintain her position.
The correct option correctly identifies that the allusion to Scylla and Charybdis, two mythical sea monsters that flanked a narrow strait, represents the two equally hazardous choices Irene faces: regulatory zeal leading to political ruin on one side, and bending to developers leading to environmental ruin on the other. It illustrates the dual, destructive forces she must navigate.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the allusion and its source context.
The text references 'Scylla and Charybdis', which are classical mythological sea hazards representing a choice between two evils.
Understanding the cultural and mythological background of the allusion is necessary to decode its symbolic function.
2
Analyze how the allusion relates to the character's conflict.
Irene is caught between the city council's wrath (regulatory zeal) and the wetlands' destruction (yielding to developers).
Connecting the allusion to the specific professional dilemma establishes the metaphorical comparison's purpose.
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that captures this analytical relationship.
The option identifying the dual destructive forces matches this analysis, while other options misinterpret the allusion or focus on irrelevant details.
Comparing candidates allows us to select the analytically sound answer while avoiding common reading errors.

Key Concept

Analyzing the function and meaning of literary allusions in short fiction to characterize internal conflict.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Metaphorical Comparisons and Allusions

More questions from this topic