Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumNarrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

Read the following passage carefully:

(1) I had, from the very onset of our acquaintance, resolved to observe Mr. Halloway with the utmost
(2) vigilance, for it was clear to me that his sudden insertion into our domestic circle at Highfield
(3) boded no good. He carried himself with an affected ease that the others, in their naive
(4) simplicity, mistook for genuine breeding. When he spoke of his travels in Italy, his descriptions
(5) of the ruins were far too rehearsed, containing none of the spontaneous enthusiasm that a true
(6) connoisseur would display. I saw how he looked at Clara—with a calculated deference that
(7) masked a predatory ambition. My cousins, of course, were charmed; even Uncle Nicholas, whose
(8) judgment is usually as sound as his investments, declared him a young man of 'remarkable promise.'
(9) But I was not so easily deceived by polished manners or a well-tailored waistcoat. Yesterday evening,
(10) when Clara dropped her fan, Halloway was quick to retrieve it, offering a remark in a low voice
(11) that made her color rise. He looked toward me then, a brief, sharp glance that was nothing less
(12) than a challenge. He knows that I see through his masquerade, and he fears the influence I wield
(13) over the family's opinions. He will try to undermine me, no doubt, but I shall remain steadfast
(14) in my duty to protect the household from this interloper, regardless of how they misinterpret
(15) my caution as mere jealousy.

The narrator's interpretation of Mr. Halloway's 'brief, sharp glance' (line 11) suggests that the narrator's perspective is limited by which of the following?

  1. A
    an accurate recognition of Halloway's calculated hostility and threat to the family
  2. B
    the author's critique of the superficiality and moral decline of the landed gentry
  3. C
    a literal observation of Halloway's physical actions when returning Clara's dropped fan
  4. a defensive projection of the narrator's own jealousy and anxiety about his status in the householdAnswer
  5. E
    a literal acceptance of Halloway's fear of the narrator's influence in the household

Answer

a defensive projection of the narrator's own jealousy and anxiety about his status in the household
The correct answer identifies that the narrator projects their own feelings of rivalry and jealousy onto Mr. Halloway. By interpreting a simple glance as a direct challenge to their influence over the family, the narrator reveals their own preoccupation with social standing and insecurity rather than Halloway's actual motives, which is underscored by the narrator's final admission that others see their caution as 'mere jealousy.'

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the narrator's claims about Halloway throughout the passage.
The narrator consistently assumes Halloway is a fraud and a threat, describing him as having 'affected ease' and 'calculated deference.'
Establishing the narrator's general disposition toward Halloway helps contextualize specific interactions.
2
Examine the specific interaction in line 11 regarding the 'brief, sharp glance.'
The narrator claims Halloway's glance is a 'challenge' because Halloway 'fears the influence' the narrator has. However, the narrator also notes that the family views the narrator's own behavior as 'mere jealousy.'
This contrasts the narrator's highly subjective, self-important view with the family's alternative interpretation of the narrator's behavior.
3
Synthesize the narrator's reliability and bias.
The narrator's assertion that Halloway is challenging him is not backed by objective facts, but rather reflects the narrator's own jealousy and fear of losing his status in the family to a new male figure.
Connecting the subjective reading of the glance to the narrator's underlying insecurity yields the correct analysis of perspective bias.

Key Concept

Narrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias
Rate this question

Topics

Narrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

More questions from this topic