Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumHistorical and Cultural Context

Read the following translated excerpt from the essay 'Nuestra América' (1891) by the Cuban writer José Martí:

'The government must originate in the country; the spirit of government must be that of the country. Its structure must conform to local conditions. Government is nothing more than the direct steering of the national elements... To govern is to create.'

Which of the following historical challenges of late nineteenth-century Latin America most directly prompted Martí's argument?

  1. A
    The immediate political reorganization of the colonies by the Spanish Crown during the initial sixteenth-century conquests.
  2. B
    The emergence of Cold War alliances that polarized the region between capitalist and communist ideologies in the mid-twentieth century.
  3. The tendency of newly independent nations to adopt foreign political and cultural models that failed to reflect their diverse populations and local realities.Answer
  4. D
    The total isolation of Latin American nations from global commerce due to a lack of interest in international trade.

Answer

The tendency of newly independent nations to adopt foreign political and cultural models that failed to reflect their diverse populations and local realities.
The correct option is supported because José Martí wrote 'Nuestra América' during a period of post-colonial nation-building when many Latin American countries struggled with instability because they adopted governance styles from Europe or the United States that did not align with their indigenous and mixed-race realities. Martí's text calls for systems of government that grow from the local culture and address the unique needs of the population.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source text to identify the author's primary argument about governance.
The author asserts that government must originate within the country, conform to local conditions, and avoid copying external models.
This establishes the core theme of the passage, which focuses on authentic self-governance.
2
Relate the author's argument to the historical context of late nineteenth-century Latin America.
During this post-independence period, Latin American nations frequently adopted constitutional models from France or the United States, leading to political instability because they ignored local social and cultural realities.
This connects the text to its historical milieu as required by the historical and cultural context learning objective.
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that accurately describes this historical challenge.
The option highlighting the adoption of foreign political and cultural models that did not fit local realities is the only correct choice.
This option matches the socio-political context of the late nineteenth century and the author's specific criticism.

Key Concept

Identifying how historical and cultural factors, such as post-colonial nation-building and the tension between native and imported political frameworks, influence literary themes and perspectives in nineteenth-century Latin American texts.
Rate this question

Topics

Historical and Cultural Context

More questions from this topic