Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumDrawing Conclusions and Making Inferences

Read the following excerpt from a journalistic feature on conservation policies in Tierra del Fuego:

"In the peatlands of Tierra del Fuego, carbon accumulation occurs at five times the rate of tropical rainforests per square meter. However, the commercial extraction of sphagnum moss for export as horticultural substrate has degraded thousands of hectares. While national environmental regulators celebrate new statutory bans on industrial moss harvesting, rural artisanal gatherers who rely on seasonal cutting for subsistence have been omitted from the transition subsidies offered to industrial corporations. Consequently, informal harvesting networks have begun operating across previously untouched private reserves, where enforcement rangers lack legal jurisdiction to intervene."

Based on the excerpt, what can be logically inferred about the overall impact of the recent regulatory reforms?

  1. A
    The statutory bans have successfully halted the ecological degradation of sphagnum moss throughout the entire region.
  2. B
    Private landowners will establish independent conservation ranger units to legally prosecute informal gatherers.
  3. By excluding small-scale gatherers from economic support, the policy inadvertently displaced ecological pressure to previously intact ecosystems.Answer
  4. D
    The author believes industrial corporations were treated unfairly compared to artisanal gatherers during the subsidy distribution.

Answer

By excluding small-scale gatherers from economic support, the policy inadvertently displaced ecological pressure to previously intact ecosystems.
The text directly states that artisanal workers were omitted from subsidies and subsequently formed informal networks targeting previously untouched private lands where rangers have no authority. It is therefore logical to infer that the regulatory framework unintentionally displaced extraction activity into vulnerable, unregulated areas.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the cause-and-effect structure in the passage
Identified that industrial bans were enacted, subsidies were restricted to corporations, and artisanal gatherers received no financial assistance.
Understanding the policy conditions establishes the direct motivation for subsequent human behavior.
2
Synthesize the unintended consequences described at the end of the text
Observed that artisanal gatherers formed informal networks operating in previously undisturbed private reserves lacking regulatory oversight.
Connecting economic exclusion to the shift in geographical harvesting locations allows for a sound deductive conclusion.
3
Evaluate the synthesized conclusion against the options
The statement that environmental damage was inadvertently shifted to unprotected territories accurately captures the broader implication without overreaching.
Ensures the correct answer is a grounded inference rather than an unsupported generalization or literal restatement.

Key Concept

Drawing Conclusions and Making Inferences
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Drawing Conclusions and Making Inferences

More questions from this topic