Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPolitics, Hamilton's Plan, and Foreign Policy in the New Republic

Read the excerpt below:

“From a belief, which can no longer be disguised, that the daring outrages with which it [the insurrection] was entered upon, were to be attributed, in a large degree, to the self-created societies, which have been active in disseminating suspicions and jealousies of the Government... It has been a spectacle, displaying the highest degree of patriotism, to see the citizen-soldier, from every class of life, assemble at the call of the laws, and perform a march of some hundreds of miles... to support the Constitution.”
—President George Washington, Sixth Annual Address to Congress, November 1794

The developments described in the excerpt most directly reflect which of the following conflicts in the 1790s?

  1. Disagreements over the scope of federal authority and its power to enforce domestic lawAnswer
  2. B
    Democratic-Republican advocacy for the armed overthrow of federal taxation policies
  3. C
    Demands by western settlers to return to the governing structure of the Articles of Confederation
  4. D
    Federalist attempts to permanently ban opposition political organizations and public assemblies

Answer

Disagreements over the scope of federal authority and its power to enforce domestic law
The correct answer is the option focusing on disagreements over the scope of federal authority and its power to enforce domestic law. President Washington's deployment of the militia to put down the Whiskey Rebellion demonstrated that the new federal government possessed the strength and constitutional authority to enforce domestic laws, a point of sharp disagreement for Democratic-Republicans who feared federal tyranny.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical context of the stimulus.
The excerpt is from George Washington's 1794 address referring to the Whiskey Rebellion (the 'insurrection') and the political clubs ('self-created societies') that opposed the excise tax.
Identifying the event and the actors helps determine the underlying political debate.
2
Connect the event to the broader political debates of the early republic.
The Federalist administration asserted that the Constitution gave the federal government the power to enforce its laws using military force, while critics feared this set a dangerous precedent of executive overreach.
This links the specific military action to the constitutional conflict between the Federalists and Democratic-Republicans.
3
Select the option that matches this constitutional conflict.
The option stating there were disagreements over the scope of federal authority and domestic law enforcement correctly identifies the central issue.
It aligns with the historical reality that the Whiskey Rebellion tested and proved the domestic sovereignty of the federal government under the Constitution.

Key Concept

Federal power and domestic sovereignty under the Constitution
Rate this question

Topics

Politics, Hamilton's Plan, and Foreign Policy in the New Republic

More questions from this topic