Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPolitics, Hamilton's Plan, and Foreign Policy in the New Republic

Read the excerpt below:

"I. Keep up a national debt, and let it be as large as possible. The funding of it will create a large class of wealthy creditors who will always support the government...
II. Establish a national bank, and let the wealthy citizens have the exclusive management of it...
III. Encourage the growth of manufacturing at the expense of agriculture, so as to create a dependency of the poor upon the rich."
— Philip Freneau, "Rules for Changing a Republic into a Monarchy," *National Gazette*, 1792

Which of the following historical developments during the 1790s best explains the perspective expressed in the excerpt?

  1. The debate over Alexander Hamilton's financial plan, which critics argued would centralize power and favor commercial interests.Answer
  2. B
    The opposition of Anti-Federalists to the ratification of the Constitution due to the lack of a bill of rights.
  3. C
    The consensus between political parties to support the Neutrality Proclamation to protect American shipping.
  4. D
    The support among Federalists for an agrarian economy that would limit the growth of industrial cities.

Answer

The debate over Alexander Hamilton's financial plan, which critics argued would centralize power and favor commercial interests.
The correct answer is the option describing the debate over Alexander Hamilton's financial plan. Philip Freneau's satirical essay directly critiques the main pillars of Hamilton's economic program—specifically, the assumption and funding of the national debt, the creation of the Bank of the United States, and the promotion of manufacturing (as outlined in Hamilton's Report on Manufactures). Democratic-Republicans feared these measures would enrich a small class of northern merchants and speculators, consolidate federal power, and ultimately subvert republican government in favor of a British-style monarchy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided stimulus to identify the author's tone and subject matter.
The author, writing in 1792, uses satire ('Rules for Changing a Republic into a Monarchy') to critique policies related to a national debt, a national bank, and the encouragement of manufacturing at the expense of agriculture.
Understanding the core arguments in the text helps link it to the specific historical debates of the 1790s.
2
Associate these issues with the political conflicts of the early republic.
The focus on the national debt, a national bank, and manufacturing directly corresponds to Alexander Hamilton's financial program, which was championed by the Federalist Party.
This links the details of the text to the central policy divisions of the period.
3
Determine the factional perspective of the author and evaluate the options.
The author opposes these policies, arguing they will concentrate power and lead to monarchy. This represents the Democratic-Republican perspective, led by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, who feared Federalist centralization. The option pointing to the debate over Hamilton's financial plan is therefore the correct choice.
Matching the critical tone of the excerpt to the corresponding political faction confirms the correct answer.

Key Concept

The rise of the first party system (Federalists vs. Democratic-Republicans) driven by debates over Alexander Hamilton's economic program.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Politics, Hamilton's Plan, and Foreign Policy in the New Republic

More questions from this topic