Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Medium21st-Century Environmental Challenges and Energy Policy

"The American Clean Energy and Security Act... is a unilateral policy that will impose significant costs on U.S. manufacturers, leading to job losses and outsourcing to countries with less stringent environmental regulations like China and India. Instead of fostering green jobs, this cap-and-trade system will act as a energy tax on American consumers, reducing our global competitiveness while failing to significantly reduce global greenhouse gas emissions."

— Representative Mike Pence, Speech on the House Floor, June 2009

Based on the excerpt, the debate surrounding the legislation most directly reflects which of the following developments in the early twenty-first century?

  1. A
    A bipartisan consensus that supply-side policies should include federal subsidies and government spending for green energy
  2. B
    A foreign policy shift that prioritized international climate treaties over unilateral national security measures
  3. Growing political polarization over the extent of federal regulatory authority and its impact on the economyAnswer
  4. D
    The successful revival of Great Society-era coalitions to pass sweeping federal conservation acts

Answer

Growing political polarization over the extent of federal regulatory authority and its impact on the economy
The correct answer is correct because the debate over the American Clean Energy and Security Act (Waxman-Markey) of 2009 illustrates the deep political division between those advocating for federal action to address climate change and those concerned about the economic costs and regulatory burdens of such policies. This polarization has defined 21st-century environmental and energy debates.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus context and the arguments presented in the excerpt.
The speaker opposes the cap-and-trade bill by arguing that federal environmental regulations harm economic growth, raise consumer costs, and reduce international competitiveness.
Identifying the core argument is necessary to connect it to broader historical themes of the period.
2
Connect the debate over the bill to major political and economic themes of the 21st century (Period 9).
The debate represents the conflict between environmental protection efforts and free-market conservatism, a key driver of political polarization in modern U.S. history.
This links the specific policy debate to the larger historical developments of the era.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that accurately characterizes this dynamic without historical misconceptions.
The option highlighting growing political polarization over federal regulatory power is correct, while other options contain historical inaccuracies or conflations.
This confirms the correct option based on historical consensus and the stimulus.

Key Concept

The political conflict in the 21st century over environmental regulations versus economic interests.
Rate this question

Topics

21st-Century Environmental Challenges and Energy Policy

More questions from this topic