Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Medium21st-Century Environmental Challenges and Energy Policy

"We must always remember that the economic prosperity of the United States is linked directly to our energy security. While we recognize the long-term challenges posed by global climate change, we cannot support international treaties like the Kyoto Protocol. Doing so would place an unfair economic burden on American industries and workers while exempting major developing economies from similar emissions restrictions. Instead, the United States will lead through technological innovation, public-private partnerships, and voluntary reduction targets that preserve economic growth."

— President George W. Bush, speech on climate change policy, 2001

Which of the following debates in late-twentieth and early-twenty-first-century United States politics does the excerpt best reflect?

  1. The conflict between global environmental treaties and national economic interestsAnswer
  2. B
    The promotion of supply-side economics through increased federal spending on clean infrastructure
  3. C
    A return to a strictly laissez-faire economic system with no federal regulation of the energy sector
  4. D
    The alignment of global climate policies with post-9/11 preemptive military containment strategy

Answer

The conflict between global environmental treaties and national economic interests
The correct option is correct because the passage shows the Bush administration's opposition to the Kyoto Protocol on the grounds that it would damage the domestic economy while exempting developing nations. This highlights the recurring debate between participating in global climate initiatives and safeguarding national economic competitiveness.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus document and identify its primary argument.
The author (President George W. Bush) argues against joining the Kyoto Protocol because it would place an unfair economic burden on the United States and exempt developing nations, suggesting instead that economic growth and voluntary partnerships should drive environmental solutions.
This establishes the core perspective of the U.S. government on international climate action in the early 21st century.
2
Evaluate the choices to find which one aligns with this central argument.
The debate over global climate treaties versus domestic economic concerns directly matches the president's justification for rejecting the treaty.
This links the specific historical event (Kyoto Protocol rejection) to the broader thematic debate in AP U.S. History Period 9.

Key Concept

The ongoing tension in U.S. politics between international environmental obligations and national economic interests during the late 20th and early 21st centuries.
Rate this question

Topics

21st-Century Environmental Challenges and Energy Policy

More questions from this topic