Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumRise of Industrial Capitalism and Business Consolidation

Source: Henry Demarest Lloyd, Wealth Against Commonwealth, 1894

"Nature is rich; but everywhere, under the dedicating operations of the trust and the monopoly, we see the production of the necessities of life restricted, prices artificially raised, and the independent producer driven to the wall. This consolidation of capital is not the natural result of free competition, but rather its destruction by means of secret railroad rebates and legislative privilege."

Which of the following historical developments during the late nineteenth century best supports Lloyd’s assertion regarding the role of "legislative privilege" in corporate consolidation?

  1. The federal government’s policy of granting public land subsidies and low-interest loans to transcontinental railroad companiesAnswer
  2. B
    The federal government’s strict adherence to laissez-faire principles, which prevented any direct or indirect intervention in the market
  3. C
    The implementation of mercantilist trade restrictions designed to limit domestic manufacturing in favor of raw material production
  4. D
    The immediate and widespread use of the Sherman Antitrust Act by the executive branch to break up corporate monopolies in the 1890s

Answer

The federal government’s policy of granting public land subsidies and low-interest loans to transcontinental railroad companies
The correct answer is the option describing public land subsidies and loans because these legislative measures directly facilitated the expansion and consolidation of the transcontinental railroads, which in turn unified national markets and accelerated industrial growth. This directly supports Lloyd's argument that government-provided privileges, rather than natural market forces alone, shaped the rise of Gilded Age monopolies.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus
Identify that Henry Demarest Lloyd critiqued business consolidation (monopolies and trusts) and argued that it was enabled by 'secret railroad rebates and legislative privilege' rather than free competition.
Understanding the core argument of the source is necessary to identify which historical evidence aligns with it.
2
Evaluate Gilded Age government actions in relation to 'legislative privilege'
Recognize that while the Gilded Age is often associated with laissez-faire rhetoric, the federal government actively supported industrial capitalism through legislative acts, such as the Pacific Railway Acts (providing land grants and subsidies) and protective tariffs.
This links the concept of 'legislative privilege' to specific federal policies that favored corporate consolidation.
3
Select the option that represents federal support for business
The option describing public land subsidies and low-interest loans to transcontinental railroads represents a direct legislative privilege that enabled consolidation of the railroad industry and broader economic integration.
This matches the correct historical development with the claim made in the stimulus.

Key Concept

Government intervention and support for Gilded Age business consolidation
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Rise of Industrial Capitalism and Business Consolidation

More questions from this topic