Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardProgressive Era Reforms and Influences

Source: Gifford Pinchot, *The Fight for Conservation*, 1910

"The first principle of conservation is development, the use of the natural resources now existing on this continent for the benefit of the people who live here now. There may be just as much waste in neglecting the development and use of certain natural resources as there is in their destruction... The second principle is the prevention of waste... Conservation stands for the development of a country first of all, and also for its preservation."

The debate described in the excerpt was most directly characterized by a conflict between the author's viewpoint and which of the following perspectives?

  1. The advocacy for the complete preservation of wilderness areas in their natural state.Answer
  2. B
    The demand by corporate interests for a return to completely unregulated laissez-faire resource extraction.
  3. C
    The agrarian Populist goal to nationalize natural resource ownership under federal control.
  4. D
    The isolationist effort to restrict foreign trade to preserve domestic resource reserves.

Answer

The advocacy for the complete preservation of wilderness areas in their natural state.
Gifford Pinchot's utilitarian view of conservation focused on the planned, efficient development of natural resources for human benefit, which directly clashed with the preservationist perspective, championed by figures like John Muir, who argued that nature should be kept pristine and protected from any commercial development.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus context, noting that the author Gifford Pinchot was the head of the U.S. Forest Service under Theodore Roosevelt and advocated for conservation.
Identify that the text advocates for the 'development' and 'prevention of waste' of natural resources for the benefit of humans (utilitarian conservation).
Understanding Pinchot's perspective is necessary to compare it to other historical viewpoints of the era.
2
Identify the primary competing viewpoint during the Progressive Era regarding public lands and environmental resource management.
Preservationists, led by figures like John Muir, advocated for protecting nature in its pristine, wild state from commercial or developmental use.
This contrasts with Pinchot's goal of controlled development.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one representing this competing preservationist viewpoint.
The option advocating for the complete preservation of wilderness areas represents the preservationist stance that directly clashed with Pinchot's conservationism.
This establishes the historical conflict between conservationists and preservationists in the Progressive Era.

Key Concept

Debates over conservation vs. preservation of natural resources during the Progressive Era
Rate this question

Topics

Progressive Era Reforms and Influences

More questions from this topic