Question

Difficulty: EasySpanish Encomienda and Labor Systems

“Since the native Indians of these islands are weak and of small strength, and are rapidly decreasing in numbers because of the heavy labor in the mines, we should grant permission for the introduction of black slaves from Africa. They are much stronger and better suited for such arduous work, and their labor will allow the sugar mills and gold mines to continue operating while relieving the surviving Indians of their heavy burdens.”

— Spanish colonial officials in Santo Domingo, letter to the Spanish Crown, 1518

The ideas expressed in the excerpt best reflect which of the following historical developments in the Spanish colonies during the sixteenth century?

  1. A
    The transformation of the encomienda from a system of coerced labor tribute to a system of outright land grants for Spanish settlers
  2. B
    The decision of the Spanish Crown to replace Indigenous laborers with European indentured servants
  3. The gradual transition from relying on coerced Indigenous labor to importing enslaved AfricansAnswer
  4. D
    The complete replacement of colonial labor systems with trade agreements that imported crops exclusively from Europe

Answer

The gradual transition from relying on coerced Indigenous labor to importing enslaved Africans
The correct option is correct because Spanish colonial officials sought to import enslaved Africans to replace the rapidly declining Indigenous population, who were dying from European diseases and harsh labor demands under early colonial systems like the encomienda.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the context and content of the source.
The letter, written by Spanish officials in 1518, notes the demographic collapse of the Indigenous population ('rapidly decreasing in numbers') and recommends importing West Africans to do the hard labor.
This establishes that the colonial economy was facing a severe labor crisis due to the deaths of Indigenous workers.
2
Evaluate the options to identify which historical process is represented by the officials' proposal.
The proposal to substitute declining Indigenous labor with African labor represents the historical transition from the encomienda system to the transatlantic slave trade.
This links the evidence from the primary source directly to the correct historical development in Period 1.

Key Concept

The transition from the encomienda system to African chattel slavery in the Spanish colonial empire due to the demographic collapse of Indigenous populations.
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question