Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardWestward Expansion: Economic and Social Development

"The transition from the simple placer washing of the early prospectors to the deep-shaft silver mining of the Comstock Lode has completely revolutionized the character of Western labor. The independent miner, who once worked his own claim with a pan and rocker, has largely disappeared. In his place stands the wage laborer, employed by massive corporate syndicates that possess the capital required to purchase expensive machinery, pump water from the depths, and construct timbered shafts. The frontier miner is no longer an independent adventurer, but a member of an organized industrial workforce."

— Eliot Lord, *Comstock Mining and Miners*, 1883

Which of the following was a direct social consequence of the economic consolidation described in the passage?

  1. The growth of labor organizations and collective resistance among miners to combat corporate control and hazardous working conditions.Answer
  2. B
    The federal government's strict adherence to laissez-faire principles, preventing state or national troops from intervening in Western mining strikes.
  3. C
    The formation of urban Progressive coalitions that successfully dismantled Western mining trusts and redistributed corporate assets to wage laborers.
  4. D
    The beginning of the Market Revolution, which connected regional economies and introduced the concept of wage labor to the American West.

Answer

The growth of labor organizations and collective resistance among miners to combat corporate control and hazardous working conditions.
The correct option is correct because the shift from individual placer mining to corporate deep-shaft mining transformed independent prospectors into industrial wage laborers. Faced with hazardous conditions, long hours, and low wages, Western miners formed collective organizations like the Western Federation of Miners to advocate for their safety and economic security.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus passage.
The passage describes the shift from individual, small-scale 'placer' mining to capital-intensive, corporate-controlled 'deep-shaft' mining on the Comstock Lode in the late nineteenth century.
Understanding the core shift from independent labor to wage labor under corporate syndicates is necessary to identify the social consequences.
2
Evaluate the social consequences of industrial wage labor in mining.
Miners faced dangerous, deep-shaft conditions (extreme heat, cave-ins, toxic gases) and lost control over their working conditions and wages.
Connecting the economic structure of corporate mining to the lived experiences of the workers helps identify their historical response.
3
Identify the historical response of Western wage laborers.
Workers organized unions, such as the Western Federation of Miners, to wage strikes and demand safer environments and fair wages.
Matching the social reality to the correct option provides the historically accurate outcome of labor consolidation.

Key Concept

The transition of Western mining from individual prospecting to corporate consolidation and the subsequent rise of industrial wage labor and unionization.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Westward Expansion: Economic and Social Development

More questions from this topic