Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardIdeological and Legal Debates over Slavery

"We arraign this bill as a gross violation of a sacred pledge; as a criminal betrayal of precious rights; as a part and parcel of an atrocious plot to exclude from a vast unoccupied region immigrants from the Old World and free laborers from the States, and convert it into a dreary region of despotism, inhabited by masters and slaves. . . .

We implore the Christian clergy of the United States, and all communities of Christian faith, to interpose their solemn protest against this catastrophe. We implore the people to rise in their might, and by petitions, by memorials, by resolutions, by votes, by all peaceable and constitutional means, to prevent the consummation of this great crime against humanity and against God."
— Salmon P. Chase et al., "Appeal of the Independent Democrats," 1854

The political opposition expressed in the excerpt most directly contributed to which of the following developments?

  1. A
    The strengthening of the bipartisan consensus behind popular sovereignty as a permanent solution to the slavery question
  2. B
    The adoption of federal tariffs that disproportionately burdened Southern agricultural states, accelerating secessionist sentiment
  3. The collapse of the Whig Party and the subsequent rise of a sectional Republican PartyAnswer
  4. D
    The establishment of state-regulated indentured servitude contracts to replace coerced labor in the newly organized territories

Answer

The collapse of the Whig Party and the subsequent rise of a sectional Republican Party
The correct answer is correct because the 'bill' referenced in the 1854 document is the Kansas-Nebraska Act, which introduced popular sovereignty to the Nebraska Territory. This bill outraged Northern free-soilers and anti-slavery Democrats, destroying the Whig Party's national unity and directly sparking the formation of the Republican Party, a sectional party dedicated to halting slavery's expansion.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source document's context and date (1854) to identify the legislative measure being criticized.
The 'bill' refers to the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854, which proposed allowing popular sovereignty to determine the status of slavery in the remaining unorganized portions of the Louisiana Purchase.
Identifying the specific historical event is necessary to understand the political reactions and consequences that followed.
2
Interpret the authors' primary arguments and concerns in the passage.
The authors argue that the bill violates a 'sacred pledge' (the Missouri Compromise of 1820) and threatens to exclude free laborers and immigrants by expanding slave labor ('dreary region of despotism').
This helps identify the ideological free-soil and moral arguments motivating the opposition.
3
Connect the opposition to the Kansas-Nebraska Act to the broader political realignment of the 1850s.
The intense Northern opposition to the act fractured the Whig Party along sectional lines and led to the creation of the Republican Party, which united former Whigs, Free-Soilers, and anti-slavery Democrats.
This directly links the stimulus to the correct historical outcome.

Key Concept

The Kansas-Nebraska Act and the resulting political realignment of the 1850s.
Rate this question

Topics

Ideological and Legal Debates over Slavery

More questions from this topic