Question

Difficulty: MediumWestward Migration, Frontier Conflicts, and Border Treaties

"The General Government only has the power, to treat with the one or the other, and the United States will exert this power for the benefit of both... No State, nor person, can purchase your lands, unless at some public treaty, held under the authority of the United States. This is the law of the land, and it will be observed."

— George Washington, Address to the Seneca Nation, 1790

Which of the following historical developments in the late eighteenth century best explains the federal government's policy outlined in the excerpt?

  1. The consolidation of treaty-making authority under the federal government to regulate land sales and manage relations on the western frontier.Answer
  2. B
    The decision to allow individual states to negotiate independent land cessions to satisfy local agrarian demands.
  3. C
    The inability of the national government under the Articles of Confederation to regulate western commerce and raise armies.
  4. D
    The total reliance on state-level militias to enforce boundaries due to a lack of executive power in the new federal constitution.

Answer

The consolidation of treaty-making authority under the federal government to regulate land sales and manage relations on the western frontier.
The correct option is correct because the newly ratified U.S. Constitution centralized treaty-making and commerce power in the federal government. In the Nonintercourse Act of 1790 and direct addresses like this one to the Seneca Nation, the Washington administration asserted that only the federal government had the authority to negotiate land cessions and treaties, seeking to bring order to the frontier and prevent unauthorized conflicts sparked by state governments or private settlers.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical context and source of the excerpt.
The excerpt is from George Washington in 1790, addressing the Seneca Nation shortly after the ratification of the U.S. Constitution.
Understanding the timeline and speaker helps identify the constitutional framework in place at the time.
2
Identify the core policy Washington is asserting in the address.
Washington states that only the 'General Government' has the power to treat with Native American nations and that no state or private individual can purchase their land.
This shows an assertion of federal supremacy and centralized treaty-making authority over state-level actions.
3
Connect this assertion to the broader themes of Period 3 frontier policy.
Under the new Constitution, the federal government sought to stabilize the western frontier, regulate westward migration, and prevent conflicts with Native American tribes by monopolizing diplomacy and land sales.
This matches the option describing the consolidation of treaty-making authority under the federal government.

Key Concept

Westward Migration, Frontier Conflicts, and Border Treaties
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question