Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPolitics, Hamilton's Plan, and Foreign Policy in the New Republic

Read the excerpt below.

"In making these remarks on the power of Congress, I have no intention to suggest that the bank is not a useful institution... But the question is: Has the Constitution given us the power to establish it? The power to incorporate a bank is not among the enumerated powers. It is not a power necessary and proper to carry into execution any of the enumerated powers. ... To assume it would be to subvert the very nature of a limited government."
—James Madison, Speech in the House of Representatives, February 2, 1791

Which of the following best describes the primary political debate reflected in this excerpt?

  1. The conflict between strict and loose constructionist interpretations of the Constitution.Answer
  2. B
    The attempt by opponents of the bank to restore the decentralized governance structure of the Articles of Confederation.
  3. C
    The debate over whether the federal government possessed the constitutional authority to levy excise taxes on citizens.
  4. D
    The foreign policy division regarding whether to align the nation's trade policies with Great Britain or France.

Answer

The conflict between strict and loose constructionist interpretations of the Constitution.
The correct answer is correct because Madison's speech directly addresses whether Congress has the constitutional authority to establish a national bank when that power is not explicitly listed in the document. This debate between strict constructionists (like Madison and Jefferson) and loose constructionists (like Hamilton) over the scope of the 'necessary and proper' clause was a defining feature of early American politics.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical source.
The source is James Madison's 1791 speech in the House of Representatives opposing the creation of a national bank on the grounds that the power to incorporate a bank is not explicitly enumerated in the Constitution.
Understanding the source's main argument and context is necessary to identify the broader political debate it represents.
2
Identify the key constitutional arguments in the early republic.
Madison's argument relies on strict construction (that the federal government only has powers explicitly listed in the Constitution), whereas Hamilton's plan relied on loose construction (using the 'necessary and proper' clause to justify implied powers).
Linking Madison's specific argument to the contemporary political debates over federal power allows for correct categorization of the issue.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that matches this constitutional conflict.
The conflict between strict and loose constructionist interpretations of the Constitution is the correct choice, as it directly addresses the debate over enumerated versus implied powers.
Matching the identified debate with the provided options yields the correct answer.

Key Concept

The constitutional debate over loose versus strict construction of federal power in the early republic.
Rate this question

Topics

Politics, Hamilton's Plan, and Foreign Policy in the New Republic

More questions from this topic