Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumWestward Expansion: Economic and Social Development

Source: Theodore Roosevelt, *Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail*, 1888.

"The great free ranches, with their uncontrolled herds, are now rapidly passing away. The land is being fenced in, and the sheepmen and the grangers are encroaching on the territory of the cattle king. Corporate capital from the East and from Great Britain has bought up the water rights, and the small rancher is forced to become a hired hand."

Which of the following historical developments in the late nineteenth century best explains the transition described in the excerpt?

  1. A
    The strict adherence of the federal government to laissez-faire policies, which prevented any government subsidies or land grants to Western developers.
  2. B
    The execution of the Dawes Severalty Act, which successfully protected communal Native American lands from corporate encroachment.
  3. The consolidation of land and key natural resources by well-funded corporate entities, which marginalized independent operators.Answer
  4. D
    The initiation of the Market Revolution, which dismantled corporate monopolies and returned economic independence to small-scale farmers.

Answer

The consolidation of land and key natural resources by well-funded corporate entities, which marginalized independent operators.
The correct answer is correct because the late nineteenth century saw a dramatic transition in the West from individualistic, open-range economic activities to highly consolidated, corporate-backed enterprises. As Theodore Roosevelt observes, the acquisition of water rights and fencing of land by well-capitalized corporations led to the marginalization of independent operators (small ranchers), who were increasingly forced to work as wage laborers (hired hands) for larger companies.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source text to identify the main shift taking place in the late nineteenth-century Western economy.
The text describes a shift from 'free ranches' and 'uncontrolled herds' to fenced land, where 'corporate capital' has purchased key resources like 'water rights,' forcing 'small ranchers' to become 'hired hands.'
This establishes the historical context of corporate consolidation replacing independent operators.
2
Evaluate the options against this shift to see which development best explains the transition.
The option describing corporate consolidation of resources matches the text directly. The other options either represent misconceptions about federal policies (such as the Dawes Act or laissez-faire) or refer to the wrong historical period (the Market Revolution).
This narrows down the choices to the correct answer by eliminating options that rely on historical errors.

Key Concept

The transition of the Western economy from individual and small-scale operations (like open-range ranching and placer mining) to large-scale, corporate-dominated industries that consolidated resources and wage labor.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Westward Expansion: Economic and Social Development

More questions from this topic