Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPresidential Nominations and the Electoral College

Which of the following is a correct comparison of the Electoral College system and a proposed national popular vote system?

Electoral College SystemProposed National Popular Vote System
IEncourages candidates to campaign nationwide to build a broad pluralist coalitionRestricts candidate campaigns to a few rural areas to protect minority interests
IICan result in a candidate winning the presidency while losing the national popular voteGuarantees that the winner of the national popular vote wins the presidency
IIIAllocates electoral votes proportionally based on each candidate's share of the state popular voteAllocates electoral votes based on the trustee model of congressional representation
IVGives voters in all states equal influence over the presidential election outcomeGives voters in less populated states disproportionate influence over the outcome

Which row represents the correct comparison?

  1. A
    Row I
  2. Row IIAnswer
  3. C
    Row III
  4. D
    Row IV

Answer

Row II
Row II is correct because the Electoral College's winner-take-all allocation of electors in most states means that a candidate can secure the required 270 electoral votes even if they do not win the national popular vote. In contrast, a national popular vote system would tally all individual votes nationwide, ensuring that the candidate with the most individual votes wins the presidency.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the mechanics of the Electoral College system.
Identify that because forty-eight states and Washington D.C. allocate all their electors to the state plurality winner, a candidate can win the presidency by securing 270 electoral votes while losing the national popular vote.
This establishes the factual basis for evaluating the first column of the comparison table.
2
Analyze the mechanics of a proposed national popular vote system.
Identify that a national popular vote system bypasses state-level winner-take-all mechanics, summing all individual votes nationwide and directly awarding the office to the candidate with the most votes.
This establishes the factual basis for evaluating the second column of the comparison table.
3
Compare the descriptions in Row II with the established mechanics.
Confirm that Row II accurately describes both systems, as the Electoral College has led to popular vote losers winning the presidency (e.g., 2000, 2016), while a national popular vote system mathematically guarantees that the national popular vote winner becomes president.
This identifies Row II as the correct choice.
4
Evaluate and eliminate the remaining rows.
Determine that Row I incorrect characterizes campaign incentives, Row III uses incorrect allocation methods and misapplies the trustee model, and Row IV inaccurately describes voter equality and representation under both systems.
This confirms that the other options contain clear errors and can be safely eliminated.

Key Concept

Presidential Nominations and the Electoral College
Rate this question

Topics

Presidential Nominations and the Electoral College

More questions from this topic