Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Opposition and Shadow Ministers

In the Australian system of government, while a Government Minister is responsible for managing a specific department, the Opposition appoints a 'Shadow Minister' for that same area. Which of the following best describes the core responsibilities of a Shadow Minister when the Government proposes a change to national law?

  1. To closely examine the Government's proposal for any weaknesses and to explain what the Opposition would do differently if they were in power.Answer
  2. B
    To work within the government department to assist the Minister in making sure the new law is implemented fairly across all states.
  3. C
    To provide the Governor-General with a final recommendation on whether the King should give Royal Assent to the law.

Answer

The core responsibilities of a Shadow Minister are to scrutinize the Government's work and offer alternative policies to the public.
The correct answer is correct because it identifies the two essential functions of a Shadow Minister: holding the current government accountable through detailed scrutiny and acting as a 'government in waiting' by presenting alternative policies to the voters.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary role of the Opposition in a democracy.
The Opposition acts as a 'check' on the power of the party in government.
Understanding the fundamental democratic purpose of the Opposition is necessary to narrow down specific roles.
2
Define the specific function of a 'Shadow' portfolio.
A Shadow Minister 'shadows' or mirrors a Government Minister to monitor their specific area of responsibility.
This explains why they are assigned to specific topics like Health, Education, or Defense.
3
Evaluate the specific duties when new laws are proposed.
Shadow Ministers must find flaws in the government's plans (scrutiny) and present their own party's vision (alternative policy).
This fulfills the role of being a 'Government in waiting,' ready to take over with their own plans if elected.

Key Concept

The Shadow Cabinet as a Scrutiny and Alternative Policy Body

Hints

1
Think about why the Opposition is often called a 'Government in waiting.'
2
Does a member of the Opposition have the power to actually run a government department?
3
The role involves both checking the current government's work and showing the public what they would do differently.

Practice More

Review the concept of 'Question Time' in Parliament to see how Shadow Ministers put this scrutiny into practice.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

The Opposition and Shadow Ministers

More questions from this topic