Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Opposition and Shadow Ministers

During a parliamentary debate regarding a significant new government policy, such as a major change to national healthcare, what is the specific responsibility of the 'Shadow Minister' for that portfolio?

  1. To critically assess the Government's plan, identify its potential weaknesses, and explain the Opposition's alternative approach to the public.Answer
  2. B
    To serve as a senior technical advisor to the Government Minister to help the ruling party implement the policy more effectively.
  3. C
    To act as an independent legal arbitrator who decides if the proposed policy violates the separation of powers before a vote is taken.

Answer

The Shadow Minister's responsibility is to evaluate the Government's policy, point out its flaws, and present the Opposition’s alternative plan.
The correct answer explains that a Shadow Minister's role is to evaluate the government's plans and offer an alternative. This ensures the government is held accountable for its decisions and that voters have a clear choice between different sets of policies.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the role of the Opposition in the Australian Parliament.
The Opposition is the second-largest party or coalition in the House of Representatives.
Understanding who forms the Opposition is the first step to knowing their function.
2
Define the purpose of 'Shadow Ministers' within the Opposition.
They are senior members who 'shadow' or mirror the roles of Government Ministers (e.g., Shadow Minister for Health shadows the Minister for Health).
This shows that their focus is specifically on holding a corresponding Government official accountable.
3
Determine the primary action they take during policy debates.
Their job is to scrutinize, criticize, and offer different solutions, acting as an 'alternative government'.
This distinguishes their role from that of the Government (who governs) and the Judiciary (who interprets laws).

Key Concept

The Shadow Cabinet acts as a check on the Government by providing scrutiny and alternative policies.

Hints

1
Think about whether the Opposition wants to help the Government succeed or show why they would be a better choice for the country.
2
Shadow Ministers are often called the 'alternative government' because they are ready to take over if their party wins the next election.

Practice More

Review the specific roles of the Prime Minister and the Cabinet to see how they differ from the Shadow Cabinet.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

The Opposition and Shadow Ministers

More questions from this topic