Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPeaceful Disagreement

Members of a national professional association in Australia are deeply divided over a proposed change to their code of ethics. Despite extensive consultation, the group remains unable to reach a consensus. In this situation, which of the following actions best exemplifies the Australian value of 'Peaceful Disagreement'?

  1. Participating in structured, respectful debates and using the democratic voting process to decide the matter, while acknowledging the right of others to maintain their contrary views.Answer
  2. B
    Organizing a campaign to formally censor and remove members who hold opposing views to ensure the association can present a single, unified stance to the public.
  3. C
    Engaging in aggressive verbal confrontation and personal shaming during meetings to make those with opposing views feel too uncomfortable to continue their advocacy.

Answer

Participating in structured, respectful debates and using the democratic voting process to decide the matter, while acknowledging the right of others to maintain their contrary views.
The correct answer demonstrates 'Peaceful Disagreement' by focusing on the process of respectful debate and the use of democratic systems (like voting) to resolve issues. It emphasizes that even when a final decision is made, the right of others to hold their own opinions must still be acknowledged and respected.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core requirement of 'Peaceful Disagreement' in Australian society.
The value requires that individuals and groups must be allowed to hold and express different opinions without fear of violence or intimidation.
Understanding the fundamental right to dissent is the first step in identifying the correct application of the value.
2
Evaluate the methods used to express disagreement in each scenario.
Lawful debate and voting are recognized democratic methods, whereas silencing opponents or using verbal abuse are not.
Peaceful disagreement is defined by the *manner* in which the disagreement is handled, emphasizing non-violence and respect.
3
Distinguish between 'consensus' and 'tolerance'.
In a pluralistic society like Australia, consensus is not always possible; therefore, tolerance of differing opinions is essential for maintaining peace.
The question specifies that consensus cannot be reached, highlighting that the solution lies in how the community coexists despite the division.
4
Select the option that maintains the dignity of all parties while allowing the disagreement to exist.
The correct action involves active participation in the democratic process while explicitly respecting the rights of others to disagree.
This aligns with the goal of maintaining a cohesive society even when fundamental differences persist.

Key Concept

The principle of Peaceful Disagreement allows for the expression of diverse opinions through respectful and lawful channels while rejecting all forms of intimidation and the silencing of dissent.

Hints

1
Consider which action allows everyone to keep their own opinion even if they don't agree with the final outcome.
2
Australian values reject any method of resolving conflict that relies on 'shutting down' the other side through force or fear.

Practice More

Review the section on 'Democratic Beliefs' to see how freedom of speech and the rule of law support the principle of peaceful disagreement.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Peaceful Disagreement

More questions from this topic