Question

Difficulty: HardWeight Definitions and Limits (GVWR, GCWR, Axle Weights)

A 5-axle tractor-semitrailer combination is operating on an interstate highway. The power unit has a manufacturer Gross Combination Weight Rating (GCWR) of 80000 lbs80{}000\text{ lbs}, a steering axle GAWR of 12500 lbs12{}500\text{ lbs}, and a drive tandem GAWR of 40000 lbs40{}000\text{ lbs}. The semitrailer has a tandem axle GAWR of 40000 lbs40{}000\text{ lbs}. When weighed at an official weigh station, the platform scale records the following actual weights:

- Steering axle: 11200 lbs11{}200\text{ lbs}
- Drive tandem axle: 35600 lbs35{}600\text{ lbs}
- Trailer tandem axle: 31700 lbs31{}700\text{ lbs}

Which of the following statements correctly evaluates the legal compliance of this vehicle under federal highway weight limits?

  1. A
    The vehicle is operating legally because the total combination weight of 78500 lbs78{}500\text{ lbs} is below the 80000 lbs80{}000\text{ lbs} federal maximum gross limit and within the manufacturer GCWR.
  2. B
    The vehicle is operating legally because the drive tandem load of 35600 lbs35{}600\text{ lbs} does not exceed the manufacturer drive tandem GAWR of 40000 lbs40{}000\text{ lbs}.
  3. The vehicle is overloaded because the drive tandem axle exceeds the federal limit of 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs}, despite total gross weight and manufacturer ratings being within limits.Answer
  4. D
    The vehicle is overloaded because the total combination weight exceeds the legal sum allowed for a combination vehicle with three axle groups.

Answer

The vehicle is overloaded because the drive tandem axle exceeds the federal limit of 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs}, despite total gross weight and manufacturer ratings being within limits.
Federal regulations impose two independent weight constraints: total gross combination weight (maximum 80000 lbs80{}000\text{ lbs}) and individual axle group weights (maximum 20000 lbs20{}000\text{ lbs} for a single axle and 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs} for a tandem axle). Additionally, drivers must not exceed manufacturer ratings. In this scenario, while total weight (78500 lbs78{}500\text{ lbs}) is legal and manufacturer ratings are not exceeded, the drive tandem weight of 35600 lbs35{}600\text{ lbs} exceeds the statutory tandem limit of 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs} by 1600 lbs1{}600\text{ lbs}, making the vehicle illegal to operate without adjusting the load or sliding the fifth wheel/tandems.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Calculate the actual Gross Combination Weight (GCW) by summing all axle scale weights.
Gross Combination Weight = 11200 lbs+35600 lbs+31700 lbs=78500 lbs11{}200\text{ lbs} + 35{}600\text{ lbs} + 31{}700\text{ lbs} = 78{}500\text{ lbs}.
Determines whether the total weight is within the federal statutory gross limit of 80000 lbs80{}000\text{ lbs} and the manufacturer GCWR of 80000 lbs80{}000\text{ lbs}.
2
Compare individual axle scale weights against standard federal axle limits (20000 lbs20{}000\text{ lbs} single axle, 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs} tandem axle).
Steering axle (11200 lbs≤20000 lbs11{}200\text{ lbs} \le 20{}000\text{ lbs}): legal; Trailer tandem (31700 lbs≤34000 lbs31{}700\text{ lbs} \le 34{}000\text{ lbs}): legal; Drive tandem (35600 lbs>34000 lbs35{}600\text{ lbs} > 34{}000\text{ lbs}): overloaded by 1600 lbs1{}600\text{ lbs}.
A commercial motor vehicle must comply with both gross limits and individual axle group limits.
3
Differentiate between manufacturer ratings (GAWR/GCWR) and statutory legal road limits.
Although the drive tandem weight (35600 lbs35{}600\text{ lbs}) is below the manufacturer GAWR of 40000 lbs40{}000\text{ lbs}, highway law enforces the more restrictive 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs} limit.
A vehicle cannot legally operate above statutory limits regardless of higher manufacturer ratings.

Key Concept

Compliance with federal weight limits requires satisfying both total gross combination limits (80000 lbs80{}000\text{ lbs}) and individual axle limits (20000 lbs20{}000\text{ lbs} single, 34000 lbs34{}000\text{ lbs} tandem), where the lower of statutory limits or manufacturer ratings governs.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question