Question

Difficulty: EasyTracking Structural Pivots and Transitions

For decades, urban planners assumed that increasing highway capacity was the most effective solution to traffic congestion. Early municipal studies appeared to support this view, showing temporary drops in commute times following major road expansions. However, recent empirical research in transportation economics reveals that such expansions actually induce additional driving demand, ultimately returning congestion to pre-expansion levels. Consequently, contemporary planners are shifting their focus from expanding infrastructure to managing demand through congestion pricing and public transit investments.

In the passage, the word 'However' primarily serves to do which of the following?

  1. Signal a pivot from a traditional planning assumption to recent empirical findings that contradict itAnswer
  2. B
    Introduce supporting evidence that reinforces the results of early municipal studies
  3. C
    Provide a specific example of contemporary public transit investment strategies
  4. D
    Attribute the findings of transportation economists to the personal preferences of urban planners
  5. E
    Qualify the effectiveness of demand management strategies by presenting a major drawback

Answer

The transition word 'However' signals a pivot from a traditional planning assumption to recent empirical findings that contradict it.
The transition word 'However' functions as a structural pivot that contrasts the earlier belief in highway expansion with recent empirical evidence demonstrating that expanding highways does not solve congestion long-term.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the text preceding the pivot word 'However'.
The first two sentences outline a traditional belief and early supporting studies regarding highway expansion.
Establishing the initial premise is necessary to determine what contrast is being created.
2
Analyze the text immediately following 'However'.
The sentence following 'However' presents new empirical research showing that highway expansion induces driving demand and fails to reduce congestion long-term.
Understanding the new claim reveals how it relates to the initial premise.
3
Identify the structural function of the pivot.
The pivot shifts the argument from the traditional view to a refutation based on modern empirical research.
This directly answers the stem question about the rhetorical role of 'However'.

Key Concept

Tracking Structural Pivots and Transitions
Rate this question