Question

Difficulty: EasyIdentifying Main Conclusions and Final Claims

Many city planners argue that constructing additional highway lanes is the most effective way to reduce urban traffic congestion. However, recent urban planning studies demonstrate that expanding highway capacity consistently attracts more vehicles onto the road, a phenomenon known as induced demand. Consequently, expanding highway lanes fails to deliver lasting congestion relief. Cities seeking sustainable traffic management should therefore shift their capital investments toward high-capacity public transit infrastructure.

Which of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?

  1. A
    Constructing new highway lanes is the most popular strategy currently employed by city planners to reduce traffic.
  2. B
    Expanding highway capacity leads to induced demand by encouraging more motorists to drive.
  3. C
    Adding new highway lanes does not provide a long-term solution to urban traffic congestion.
  4. Cities aiming for sustainable traffic management ought to direct their capital investments toward high-capacity public transit.Answer
  5. E
    Investing in public transit infrastructure will completely eliminate all urban traffic congestion.

Answer

Cities aiming for sustainable traffic management ought to direct their capital investments toward high-capacity public transit.
The author's primary goal is to advocate for a specific policy change: shifting traffic management investments toward high-capacity public transit. The final sentence uses the conclusion indicator 'therefore' to signal that this recommendation is the ultimate claim supported by the evidence regarding induced demand and the failure of highway expansion.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the structural role of each sentence in the passage.
Sentence 1 provides background context/opposing view; Sentence 2 provides empirical evidence (premise); Sentence 3 draws an intermediate conclusion; Sentence 4 presents the author's main recommendation.
Identifying structural roles helps isolate the final claim from supporting evidence and background information.
2
Locate conclusion keywords and pivot markers.
The word 'therefore' in the final sentence signals the author's main logical destination.
Conclusion indicators explicitly mark the primary claim supported by preceding premises.
3
Match the identified main claim with the paraphrased option.
The option advocating a shift in capital investments toward public transit precisely matches the final sentence's recommendation.
The correct option must accurately restate the author's final claim without altering its scope or tone.

Key Concept

Identifying Main Conclusions and Final Claims
Rate this question