Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardSelect-in-Passage Question Analysis

Read the passage below:

For over a century, paleoanthropologists interpreted Upper Paleolithic cave paintings primarily through the lens of sympathetic magic, proposing that early humans depicted game animals solely to ensure successful hunts. However, this utilitarian framework fails to account for the frequent depiction of dangerous carnivores rarely targeted for consumption, as well as the deliberate placement of imagery in acoustically resonant subterranean chambers unreachable during routine foraging. Recent structural analyses of parietal art suggest instead that these subterranean motifs functioned as integral components of ritualized sensory landscapes designed to induce altered states of consciousness. Specifically, archaeoacoustic mapping revealed a strong spatial correlation between the density of painted megafauna and localized resonance peaks within the cave topography. While some researchers caution that acoustic resonance could be an incidental byproduct of natural cave morphology rather than an intentional site selection factor, the systematic repetition of this spatial pattern across geographically isolated sites renders pure coincidence highly improbable.

Which sentence in the passage presents specific empirical evidence offered to support the hypothesis that cave paintings were deliberately aligned with auditory phenomena?

  1. A
    For over a century, paleoanthropologists interpreted Upper Paleolithic cave paintings primarily through the lens of sympathetic magic, proposing that early humans depicted game animals solely to ensure successful hunts.
  2. B
    However, this utilitarian framework fails to account for the frequent depiction of dangerous carnivores rarely targeted for consumption, as well as the deliberate placement of imagery in acoustically resonant subterranean chambers unreachable during routine foraging.
  3. C
    Recent structural analyses of parietal art suggest instead that these subterranean motifs functioned as integral components of ritualized sensory landscapes designed to induce altered states of consciousness.
  4. Specifically, archaeoacoustic mapping revealed a strong spatial correlation between the density of painted megafauna and localized resonance peaks within the cave topography.Answer
  5. E
    While some researchers caution that acoustic resonance could be an incidental byproduct of natural cave morphology rather than an intentional site selection factor, the systematic repetition of this spatial pattern across geographically isolated sites renders pure coincidence highly improbable.

Answer

The sentence stating that archaeoacoustic mapping revealed a strong spatial correlation between the density of painted megafauna and localized resonance peaks within the cave topography.
The correct answer is the sentence that begins with 'Specifically, archaeoacoustic mapping revealed...'. This sentence introduces specific, quantitative data (mapping results showing spatial correlation between painting density and acoustic resonance peaks) that acts as direct empirical evidence for the acoustic alignment hypothesis.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the prompt's target criteria.
The target sentence must fulfill a precise rhetorical function: presenting concrete empirical findings (data/evidence) supporting the intentional alignment of cave art with auditory phenomena.
Select-in-Passage items require distinguishing between thesis claims, negative evidence/anomalies, empirical proof, and qualifications.
2
Evaluate the rhetorical function of each sentence in the passage structure.
Sentence 1 lays out the traditional paradigm. Sentence 2 presents anomalies against the traditional view. Sentence 3 asserts a new theoretical hypothesis. Sentence 4 provides measurable data ('archaeoacoustic mapping revealed a strong spatial correlation'). Sentence 5 counters a potential skeptic's objection.
Isolating structural transitions ensures exact matching of rhetorical role.
3
Select the sentence matching the empirical evidence criterion.
The fourth sentence explicitly names the data source ('archaeoacoustic mapping') and the specific empirical result ('spatial correlation between... density of painted megafauna and localized resonance peaks').
This sentence directly fulfills the request for empirical evidence supporting the acoustic hypothesis.

Key Concept

Identifying Sentence-Level Rhetorical Functions and Empirical Evidence in Academic Text
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Select-in-Passage Question Analysis

More questions from this topic