Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumParsing Complex Syntax, Reversals, and Double Negatives

Consider the following excerpt from an analysis of municipal fiscal policy: "It cannot be gainsaid that the board was not unappreciative of the proposed reform; nonetheless, their subsequent policy choices hardly demonstrated an eager embrace of its principles." Which of the following best characterizes the board's attitude toward the proposed reform as described in the excerpt?

  1. The board acknowledged the value of the reform but acted with hesitation and limited enthusiasm.Answer
  2. B
    The board was entirely dismissive of the reform due to a fundamental failure to recognize its merits.
  3. C
    The board fully championed the reform and immediately integrated its principles into municipal policy.
  4. D
    The board maintained open hostility toward the proposal despite public support.
  5. E
    The board initially opposed the reform but eventually embraced it without reservation.

Answer

The board acknowledged the value of the reform but acted with hesitation and limited enthusiasm.
The statement combines an assertion of truth ('cannot be gainsaid') with a double negative ('not unappreciative') to convey that the board recognized the value of the reform. The contrast transition ('nonetheless') combined with 'hardly demonstrated an eager embrace' indicates that despite this recognition, their actual implementation was hesitant and lacked enthusiasm. Thus, the option highlighting that the board acknowledged the reform's value while acting with hesitation accurately reflects the text.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Parse the opening clause and double negative
'It cannot be gainsaid' means 'it cannot be denied'. 'Not unappreciative' is a double negative (litotes) meaning the board did indeed appreciate or recognize the value of the proposal to some extent.
Resolving litotes establishes the initial positive sentiment of the subject.
2
Analyze the pivot and secondary clause
'Nonetheless' signals a contrast shift. 'Hardly demonstrated an eager embrace' means their actions showed reluctance, restraint, or lack of strong commitment.
The contrast transition qualifies the initial appreciation, shifting the overall meaning from unreserved support to restrained acknowledgement.
3
Synthesize full sentence meaning and match options
The overall sentiment indicates partial/moderate appreciation paired with cautious or restrained action, matching the statement that the board acknowledged the reform's value but acted with hesitation.
The correct interpretation balances both the initial positive recognition and the subsequent qualification.

Key Concept

Parsing Double Negatives and Contrast Signals
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question

Topics

Parsing Complex Syntax, Reversals, and Double Negatives

More questions from this topic