Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumRepresentations, Warranties, and Concealment

A logistics firm applies for a commercial transit insurance policy to cover valuable cargo. During underwriting, the firm agrees to a strict contractual provision guaranteeing that every transport vehicle will utilize an active GPS tracking system during all transit operations. During a long-haul trip, a driver disables the vehicle's GPS, and the truck is subsequently hijacked. The insurer denies the cargo claim, citing that the absolute condition of coverage was broken. Which legal doctrine gives the insurer the right to void the coverage in this specific scenario?

  1. Breach of an express warranty, which requires strict and exact compliance for the policy to remain in forceAnswer
  2. B
    Material misrepresentation, because the firm provided a false statement of belief on the initial application
  3. C
    Estoppel, because the insurer is legally prevented from paying a claim on an untracked vehicle
  4. D
    Lack of legal consideration, because the failure to use the GPS retroactively invalidated the initial premium payment

Answer

Breach of an express warranty, which requires strict and exact compliance for the policy to remain in force
The correct answer accurately identifies that a strict contractual provision guaranteeing a specific ongoing condition (like maintaining an active GPS) is an express warranty. In insurance law, an express warranty requires exact and literal compliance. If the warranty is breached, the insurer has the legal right to void the coverage, even if the breach was not the direct cause of the loss.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the nature of the statement made by the insured
The firm agreed to a strict contractual provision guaranteeing the use of an active GPS system.
Identifying whether the statement is a representation or a warranty determines how strictly it must be enforced.
2
Determine the legal classification of the absolute condition
Because it is an absolute guarantee written into the contract, it is classified as an express warranty.
Warranties require literal truth or strict compliance, unlike representations which only require substantial truth.
3
Evaluate the consequence of breaking the condition
The deactivation of the GPS breached the warranty, giving the insurer the right to deny the claim and void coverage.
Breaching a warranty instantly voids the coverage regardless of materiality or intent.

Key Concept

Express Warranties in Insurance Contracts
Rate this question

Topics

Representations, Warranties, and Concealment

More questions from this topic