Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardUnfair Trade Practices

An appointed agent is attempting to win a group health insurance contract for a local school district. During a presentation to the school board, the agent hands out a printed memorandum. The memo claims that the district's current insurer, Vanguard Health, is secretly insolvent and has been placed under state receivership, meaning they will soon be unable to pay out employee medical claims. In reality, Vanguard Health is financially sound and holds excellent ratings, though they recently closed a small regional administrative office. Under the NAIC Model Unfair Trade Practices Act, which specific violation has the agent committed?

  1. Defamation, by disseminating a false and maliciously critical statement regarding a competing insurer's financial condition.Answer
  2. B
    Twisting, by utilizing deceptive statements to induce the school board to surrender their existing insurance policy.
  3. C
    False information and advertising, by distributing a printed memorandum containing misleading statements to the public.
  4. D
    Boycott, coercion, and intimidation, by using fear tactics to unreasonably restrain the district's insurance transaction.

Answer

Defamation, by disseminating a false and maliciously critical statement regarding a competing insurer's financial condition.
The correct answer accurately identifies the act of Defamation. Under state insurance regulations, defamation occurs when anyone in the insurance business makes, publishes, or circulates a statement that is false, maliciously critical, or derogatory regarding the financial condition of any person or insurer, with the intent to injure that person or insurer. By falsely telling the school board that Vanguard Health was secretly insolvent and unable to pay claims, the agent committed defamation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the agent's action
The agent distributed a memo falsely claiming a competitor was insolvent and under state receivership.
To identify the core behavior driving the regulatory violation.
2
Evaluate the nature and target of the statement
The statement was false, maliciously critical, and specifically attacked the financial condition of a competing insurer.
To differentiate between misrepresenting one's own products (False Advertising) and attacking a competitor (Defamation).
3
Apply NAIC Model Unfair Trade Practices standards
The scenario matches the exact statutory definition of Defamation.
To select the precise statutory violation from the provided choices.

Key Concept

Unfair Trade Practices: Defamation
Rate this question

Topics

Unfair Trade Practices

More questions from this topic