Question

Difficulty: MediumUnfair Trade Practices

During a private consultation, an insurance producer is attempting to close a sale on a substantial life insurance policy. To secure the business, the producer offers to pay the applicant's first month's premium out of their own pocket. When the applicant hesitates and mentions they are also considering a quote from Apex Mutual, the producer falsely states that Apex Mutual is currently under state investigation for insolvency. Which pair of statutory unfair trade practices has the producer committed in this scenario?

  1. Rebating and DefamationAnswer
  2. B
    Twisting and Coercion
  3. C
    Churning and False Advertising
  4. D
    Sliding and Unfair Discrimination

Answer

The producer has committed rebating and defamation.
The correct answer accurately identifies both statutory violations. Offering to pay the first month's premium out of pocket is an unauthorized inducement to purchase, which is legally defined as rebating. Furthermore, making a false and malicious statement regarding the financial condition of a competing insurer constitutes defamation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the producer's first action: offering to pay the applicant's first month's premium.
This action provides a valuable consideration or inducement not specified in the insurance contract.
By definition, offering an unauthorized financial incentive to induce a purchase is classified as rebating.
2
Analyze the producer's second action: falsely stating that a competing insurer is facing insolvency.
This action involves making a false, maliciously critical statement regarding the financial condition of another person or company.
Under statutory definitions, spreading false rumors about an insurer's financial solvency constitutes defamation.
3
Combine the identified violations to select the correct pair.
The scenario clearly depicts both rebating and defamation.
Matching the recognized actions to the available choices confirms the correct classification of the unfair trade practices.

Key Concept

Identifying Specific Unfair Trade Practices
Rate this question