An architectural firm applies for a life insurance policy on its principal architect, Victor, to satisfy the requirements of a commercial bank loan. The application is properly signed by the firm's managing partner and Victor. When the application reaches the insurer's underwriting department, it is discovered that a question inquiring about recent medical consultations for cardiovascular issues is entirely blank. The insurer chooses to issue the policy anyway without requesting the missing information. Six months later, Victor dies of a sudden heart attack, and medical records indicate he had seen a cardiologist shortly before the application date. What is the legal consequence of the insurer issuing the policy despite the blank question?
- The insurer waived its right to the missing medical information by issuing the policy and must pay the full death benefit.Answer
- BThe insurer is permitted to deny the claim because leaving the cardiovascular question blank constitutes an act of material concealment.
- CThe policy contract is legally void from inception because failing to answer every question means valid consideration was never established.
- DThe insurer can refuse the claim and hold the producer liable for exceeding their implied authority by submitting an incomplete application.
Answer
The insurer waived its right to the missing medical information by issuing the policy and must pay the full death benefit.
When an application contains unanswered questions, the insurer has the right to return it for completion. However, if the insurer chooses to issue the policy anyway, it legally waives its right to that information. The insurer is therefore bound by the contract and must pay the death benefit, even if the missing information would have altered their underwriting decision.
Step-by-Step Solution
Key Concept
Waiver of Information in Incomplete Applications