Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardElements of Insurable Risk

An individual investor purchases 10,000 shares of a newly formed biotechnology company. To protect this financial venture, the investor applies for a commercial insurance policy that guarantees reimbursement of the original purchase price if the stock's value drops by more than 50% over the next twelve months due to normal market volatility. Based on the elements of an insurable risk, which of the following best explains why an insurance company will reject this application?

  1. The investment represents a speculative risk because it involves the potential for both financial gain and loss, whereas insurance is designed exclusively to cover pure risks.Answer
  2. B
    The potential loss of the investment is an insurable pure risk, but the application must be rejected because stock market fluctuations are not statistically predictable.
  3. C
    The market volatility acts as a physical hazard rather than an insurable peril, making the financial loss intentional rather than accidental.
  4. D
    The investor's attempt to purchase a policy constitutes risk avoidance, which legally prohibits the insurer from covering the market depreciation.

Answer

The investment represents a speculative risk because it involves the potential for both financial gain and loss, whereas insurance is designed exclusively to cover pure risks.
The correct answer accurately identifies that investing in the stock market involves both the chance of loss and the chance of gain, which defines a speculative risk. One of the most fundamental elements of an insurable risk is that it must be a pure risk—meaning there is only a chance of loss with no opportunity for financial gain. Because the investor could profit if the stock price rises, the exposure is strictly uninsurable.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the scenario to identify the nature of the exposure being presented to the insurer.
The investor is seeking coverage for potential financial loss on a stock purchase, an asset which also has the potential to increase in value over time.
Determining whether the exposure involves only a chance of loss, or both a chance of gain and loss, is the foundational step in underwriting risk classification.
2
Apply the core elements of an insurable risk to the identified exposure.
An insurable risk must be a pure risk (involving only a chance of loss). The stock investment is a speculative risk because a profit is possible.
Insurance mechanisms are mathematically and legally designed to indemnify pure risks, not to protect speculative financial ventures from downside while allowing upside.
3
Evaluate the given options against this underwriting principle to find the correct justification for rejection.
The option stating that the investment is a speculative risk accurately identifies the missing element of an insurable risk.
This aligns perfectly with the fundamental principle that speculative risks are uninsurable.

Key Concept

Elements of Insurable Risk - Pure vs. Speculative Risk
Rate this question

Topics

Elements of Insurable Risk

More questions from this topic