Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumElements of Insurable Risk

A business owner applies for a commercial policy that would pay out $100,000 if the market value of their company's newly issued stock decreases over the next fiscal year. The insurance company rejects the application. Based on the elements of an insurable risk, which of the following best explains why this coverage was declined?

  1. The scenario involves a speculative risk, whereas insurers require a pure risk.Answer
  2. B
    The situation presents a pure risk, but the financial loss cannot be definitively measured.
  3. C
    The potential decrease in stock value is classified as a physical hazard rather than a covered peril.
  4. D
    The business owner is attempting to practice risk retention instead of risk transfer.

Answer

The scenario involves a speculative risk, whereas insurers require a pure risk.
Insurance principles dictate that only pure risks—situations where there is only a chance of loss or no loss—are insurable. The scenario describes an investment in the stock market, which is a speculative risk because it involves the potential for financial gain if the stock value increases. Therefore, it violates a primary element of an insurable risk.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the nature of the financial exposure described in the scenario.
The exposure is the market value of the company's stock, which can either decrease (resulting in a loss) or increase (resulting in a gain).
Identifying whether an exposure can result in a gain is the critical first step in classifying the type of risk.
2
Compare the exposure to the fundamental elements of an insurable risk.
Insurable risks must be pure risks (chance of loss only). The stock market exposure is a speculative risk.
Insurance is designed to indemnify (restore to pre-loss condition), not to protect investments that are intended for profit.
3
Select the option that correctly identifies the violated element of insurability.
The coverage was declined because the risk is speculative rather than pure.
This directly matches the core requirement that only pure risks are insurable.

Key Concept

Pure vs. Speculative Risk
Rate this question

Topics

Elements of Insurable Risk

More questions from this topic