Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumRepresentations, Warranties, and Concealment

Dr. Aris is applying for a professional liability insurance policy for her new medical clinic. One of the application questions asks for the exact date her state medical license was originally issued. Relying on her memory, she writes down June 15th, but official state records later reveal the actual issue date was June 5th of the same year. The underwriter confirms that this ten-day discrepancy has absolutely no impact on her eligibility for coverage or the premium charged. Based on the principles of insurance contracts, which of the following best describes the legal nature of Dr. Aris's statement and its effect on the policy?

  1. It is a representation; because the statement is substantially true and the discrepancy is not material to the risk, the policy remains fully valid.Answer
  2. B
    It is a warranty; because insurance applications require absolute factual accuracy, any deviation from the exact truth automatically gives the insurer the right to void the contract.
  3. C
    It is an administrative error; the insurance agent must unilaterally correct the date on the submitted application form without Dr. Aris's involvement to maintain coverage.
  4. D
    It is a morale hazard; the incorrect date demonstrates a careless attitude toward the application process, allowing the insurer to cancel the policy immediately.

Answer

The statement is legally a representation. Because the minor date error was not material to the underwriting decision, the policy remains fully valid.
Statements made by applicants on insurance applications are legally classified as representations, which are statements believed to be true to the best of the applicant's knowledge. For a misrepresentation to void a policy, it must be material—meaning it would have changed the insurer's underwriting decision, risk classification, or premium. Since the underwriter confirmed the ten-day discrepancy did not affect the underwriting process, it is not material, and the policy remains perfectly valid.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the legal classification of statements made by an applicant on an insurance application.
Statements made by an applicant are legally considered representations (statements believed to be true to the best of their knowledge), not warranties.
This establishes the baseline legal standard applied to the applicant's answers.
2
Evaluate the impact of the factual discrepancy in the scenario.
The ten-day difference in the license issue date did not affect eligibility or premium, meaning it is not a material misrepresentation.
A false representation only voids a policy if it is material to the risk being assumed by the insurer.
3
Determine the final effect on the insurance contract.
Since the statement is a non-material representation, the policy remains fully valid and in force.
Insurers cannot void a contract over immaterial inaccuracies that do not affect the underwriting decision.

Key Concept

Representations vs. Warranties and Materiality
Rate this question

Topics

Representations, Warranties, and Concealment

More questions from this topic