Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumWaiver and Estoppel

A business owner holds a commercial liability policy that requires all security alarms to be fully operational during non-business hours. The alarm system malfunctions, and the owner immediately notifies their insurance agent. The agent responds, 'I have noted your file; your coverage will remain fully intact while you wait for repairs next week.' The insurer's underwriting department also sends an email confirming receipt of the notice without mentioning any suspension of coverage. That weekend, a burglary occurs, and the insurer attempts to deny the claim based on the broken alarm.

Which of the following statements accurately apply the doctrines of waiver and estoppel to this situation? (Select all that apply.)

  1. The insurer's actions constitute a waiver, as they intentionally relinquished their known right to suspend coverage.Answer
  2. The doctrine of estoppel legally bars the insurer from denying the claim because the insured detrimentally relied on the agent's assurance.Answer
  3. C
    The intentional surrender of the right to suspend coverage is known as estoppel, while the legal barrier preventing the insurer from denying the claim is called a waiver.
  4. D
    The insurer retains the right to deny the claim because the agent only possessed apparent authority rather than express authority to alter the written contract.

Answer

The correct statements establish that the insurer's actions constitute a waiver (intentional relinquishment of a right) and that estoppel legally bars the insurer from denying the claim due to the insured's detrimental reliance.
The correct statements properly distinguish the two doctrines: Waiver is the insurer's voluntary decision to give up its right to enforce the alarm condition, and estoppel is the legal consequence that protects the insured because they reasonably relied on that waiver to their detriment.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the communications from the agent and the underwriting department.
They explicitly told the insured that coverage would remain fully intact despite the broken alarm condition.
To determine if the insurer voluntarily surrendered a known contractual right.
2
Apply the legal definition of waiver to the scenario.
The insurer's voluntary relinquishment of the right to suspend coverage due to the broken alarm constitutes a waiver.
To identify the legal doctrine that applies to the insurer's initial promise.
3
Apply the legal definition of estoppel to the scenario.
Because the insured relied on this assurance to their detriment (by not seeking alternative coverage or security), the insurer is estopped (prevented) from denying the claim.
To identify the legal consequence that forces the insurer to honor the claim.

Key Concept

Waiver and Estoppel in Insurance Contracts
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Waiver and Estoppel

More questions from this topic