Question

Difficulty: MediumUnfair Trade Practices

During a routine internal audit, a compliance director at a regional brokerage identifies several problematic scenarios involving producer and insurer conduct. Identify the specific statutory violation that corresponds to each documented scenario.

  • An agent verbally guarantees that non-guaranteed policy dividends will completely cover all premium payments after five years.Misrepresentation
  • An insurer refuses to issue a standard life contract to an applicant based entirely on their status as a victim of domestic abuse.Unfair Discrimination
  • An agency broadcasts a commercial that deceptively implies it is a government-sponsored program providing low-cost healthcare.False Advertising
  • Several independent agencies collude and agree to stop writing business for a specific carrier to force an increase in commission rates.Boycott

Answer

The scenarios match their respective statutory violations: the dividend guarantee is Misrepresentation, the coverage denial based on abuse status is Unfair Discrimination, the deceptive government-affiliation commercial is False Advertising, and the collusion against a carrier is Boycott.
Each scenario perfectly aligns with the statutory definition of an unfair trade practice under the NAIC Model Unfair Trade Practices standards. Misrepresentation involves false statements about policy terms; Unfair Discrimination involves non-actuarial coverage denials; False Advertising involves deceptive public media; and Boycott involves group collusion to restrict trade.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first scenario regarding guaranteed dividends.
Matches with Misrepresentation.
Making false statements or absolute guarantees about policy benefits and dividends violates statutes against misrepresenting policy terms.
2
Analyze the second scenario regarding domestic abuse status.
Matches with Unfair Discrimination.
Denying coverage without actuarial justification, specifically based on protected or specified statuses like being a victim of abuse, is legally defined as unfair discrimination.
3
Analyze the third scenario regarding the television commercial.
Matches with False Advertising.
Creating misleading impressions about government affiliations in public broadcasts is a deceptive advertising practice.
4
Analyze the fourth scenario regarding agency collusion.
Matches with Boycott.
Conspiring to withhold business to coerce a carrier into raising commissions constitutes an illegal boycott, coercion, and intimidation resulting in an unreasonable restraint of trade.

Key Concept

Unfair Trade Practices Classifications
Rate this question