Question

Difficulty: MediumModes of Heat Transfer (Conduction, Convection, and Radiation)

Two solid cylindrical copper rods, PP and QQ, are maintained under identical temperature differences across their ends. Rod PP has twice the radius and half the length of Rod QQ. What is the ratio of the rate of heat conduction through Rod PP to that through Rod QQ?

  1. 8:18 : 1Answer
  2. B
    4:14 : 1
  3. C
    2:12 : 1
  4. D
    1:81 : 8

Answer

The ratio of the rate of heat conduction through Rod PP to that through Rod QQ is 8:18 : 1.
The rate of heat conduction is given by Qt=kπr2ΔTL\frac{Q}{t} = \frac{k \pi r^2 \Delta T}{L}. For Rod PP, substituting rP=2rQr_P = 2 r_Q and LP=0.5LQL_P = 0.5 L_Q gives (2)20.5=8\frac{(2)^2}{0.5} = 8 times the rate of Rod QQ. Thus, the ratio of heat conduction rate is 8:18 : 1.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Write the fundamental equation for the rate of thermal conduction through a uniform conductor.
Qt=kAΔTL\frac{Q}{t} = \frac{k A \Delta T}{L}
Heat conduction rate is proportional to thermal conductivity kk, cross-sectional area AA, temperature difference ΔT\Delta T, and inversely proportional to length LL.
2
Express the cross-sectional area AA in terms of radius rr for a cylindrical rod.
A=πr2    Qt=kπr2ΔTLA = \pi r^2 \implies \frac{Q}{t} = \frac{k \pi r^2 \Delta T}{L}
The cross-section of a cylindrical rod is a circle.
3
Set up the ratio of heat conduction rates for Rod PP and Rod QQ given rP=2rQr_P = 2 r_Q and LP=0.5LQL_P = 0.5 L_Q.
(Q/t)P(Q/t)Q=rP2/LPrQ2/LQ=(2rQ)2/(0.5LQ)rQ2/LQ=40.5=8\frac{(Q/t)_P}{(Q/t)_Q} = \frac{r_P^2 / L_P}{r_Q^2 / L_Q} = \frac{(2 r_Q)^2 / (0.5 L_Q)}{r_Q^2 / L_Q} = \frac{4}{0.5} = 8
Material (kk) and temperature difference (ΔT\Delta T) are identical for both rods and cancel out.

Key Concept

Thermal Conduction Rate Formula
Rate this question