Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardReinsurance, Co-insurance, and Underwriting Concepts

Apex Logistics Ltd insured its commercial cargo vessel valued at ₦500 million against marine risks with Anchor Insurance Plc. To manage its liability exposure, Anchor Insurance Plc transferred 60% of the insured risk to Beacon Reinsurance Ltd under a separate treaty contract. In the event of a total loss, what is the direct legal standing of Apex Logistics Ltd regarding financial recovery?

  1. Recovering the entire ₦500 million compensation directly from Anchor Insurance Plc.Answer
  2. B
    Filing simultaneous separate claims of ₦200 million from Anchor Insurance Plc and ₦300 million from Beacon Reinsurance Ltd.
  3. C
    Claiming ₦300 million directly from Beacon Reinsurance Ltd as a co-insurer of the vessel.
  4. D
    Recovering ₦300 million from Beacon Reinsurance Ltd only if Anchor Insurance Plc becomes insolvent.

Answer

Apex Logistics Ltd must recover the entire ₦500 million compensation directly from Anchor Insurance Plc because privity of contract exists exclusively between the policyholder and the primary insurer.
Under insurance law, privity of contract exists strictly between the insured policyholder and the primary insurer. Therefore, Apex Logistics Ltd must claim the entire ₦500 million indemnity directly from Anchor Insurance Plc. The reinsurance agreement between Anchor Insurance Plc and Beacon Reinsurance Ltd is an independent contract to which Apex Logistics Ltd is not a party.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the nature of the risk-sharing agreement between Anchor Insurance Plc and Beacon Reinsurance Ltd.
The agreement is a reinsurance arrangement where the primary insurer (Anchor Insurance Plc) cedes a portion of its accepted risk to a reinsurer (Beacon Reinsurance Ltd).
Reinsurance involves an insurance company insuring itself against loss on policies it has issued.
2
Determine the legal relationship (privity of contract) between the insured (Apex Logistics Ltd) and the entities involved.
Apex Logistics Ltd holds a direct insurance policy only with Anchor Insurance Plc. There is no contractual relationship between Apex Logistics Ltd and Beacon Reinsurance Ltd.
In reinsurance, the insured is not a party to the reinsurance contract and cannot sue or directly claim from the reinsurer.
3
Formulate the correct claim recovery procedure upon total loss.
Apex Logistics Ltd must claim the total indemnity of ₦500 million from Anchor Insurance Plc. Anchor Insurance Plc will separately settle its ₦300 million (60%) recovery from Beacon Reinsurance Ltd behind the scenes.
The primary insurer remains fully liable for 100% of the insured sum to the policyholder regardless of reinsurance arrangements.

Key Concept

Reinsurance vs Co-insurance Privity of Contract
Rate this question

Topics

Reinsurance, Co-insurance, and Underwriting Concepts

More questions from this topic