Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyJudicial Independence and the Enforcement of the Rule of Law

Which institutional mechanism directly prevents the executive arm of government from arbitrarily dismissing judicial officers from office?

  1. Security of tenure guaranteed by constitutional provisionsAnswer
  2. B
    Absolute lifetime immunity of judges from criminal investigation
  3. C
    The legislative power to impeach the head of state
  4. D
    Unilateral executive authority to appoint judges without oversight

Answer

Security of tenure guaranteed by constitutional provisions
Security of tenure guarantees that judicial officers retain their posts until reaching a constitutionally mandated age or following a stringent removal process involving judicial councils and legislative confirmation. This prevents the executive from dismissing judges who rule against government actions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the core principle being tested
The core principle is judicial independence and how judges are shielded from political control.
Judicial independence requires mechanisms that protect judges from executive influence or arbitrary punishment.
2
Evaluate the mechanism that specifically protects judges from arbitrary dismissal
Security of tenure ensures judges hold office until a mandatory retirement age or can only be removed through strict, independent constitutional procedures.
Without security of tenure, judges would fear executive dismissal when delivering judgments against government interests.

Key Concept

Judicial Security of Tenure
Rate this question

Topics

Judicial Independence and the Enforcement of the Rule of Law

More questions from this topic