Question

Difficulty: MediumBridging Conflicting Premises

Match each paradoxical scenario on the left with the additional piece of information on the right that most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy.

  • A boutique bakery raised the prices of its signature pastries significantly, yet the total volume of these pastries sold per week increased.The price increase coincided with a viral social media trend that rebranded the pastries as an exclusive luxury item, drawing in thousands of new customers.
  • A municipality initiated a massive tree-planting campaign specifically to lower summer temperatures, but the average summer heat in the targeted neighborhoods actually rose.The campaign was concentrated in areas where developers had just paved over large green spaces with dark, heat-absorbing asphalt.
  • A regional airline significantly reduced its scheduled flights to rural airports, expecting a loss, yet its total revenue from rural routes increased.By cutting the number of flights, the airline achieved a monopoly on the remaining essential routes, allowing it to drastically increase ticket prices.
  • A university made its premium lecture recordings freely accessible to attract more paying students, but subsequent enrollment in its paid online certificate programs dropped.The freely available recordings provided all the necessary educational content, eliminating the primary incentive for students to pay for the formal programs.

Answer

The bakery matches the social media luxury trend; the tree-planting matches the asphalt paving; the airline matches the monopoly pricing; the university lectures matches the educational substitution effect.
Each correct pairing provides the missing contextual factor that allows both seemingly incompatible premises in the scenario to coexist logically. They supply alternative causes, overriding variables, or mathematical relationships (like price versus volume) that resolve the apparent discrepancies.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the bakery scenario
Identify the paradox: higher prices usually mean lower sales volume, but here volume increased.
Understanding the core conflict is necessary to find the bridge.
2
Match the bakery scenario
Pair it with the social media luxury trend resolution.
This introduces a shift in demand that overrides the normal effect of a price increase.
3
Analyze and match the tree-planting scenario
Pair the tree-planting (which should cool the area) with the asphalt paving (which heats the area).
The asphalt introduces an external variable that causes the unexpected temperature rise.
4
Analyze and match the airline scenario
Pair the reduced flights with monopoly pricing.
Revenue equals volume times price; if volume drops but revenue rises, price must have increased significantly to compensate.
5
Analyze and match the university scenario
Pair the free lectures with the elimination of the incentive to pay.
This explains why the promotional effort perfectly substituted the paid product and reduced paid enrollments.

Key Concept

Bridging Conflicting Premises by identifying external variables, offsetting factors, or unintended behavioral consequences.
Rate this question