Question

Difficulty: MediumExplicit Main Point Identification

[1] The recent resurgence of interest in "degrowth" economics—a movement advocating for the intentional reduction of global production and consumption—has sparked vigorous debate among ecological economists. [2] Advocates of degrowth contend that infinite economic expansion is biophysically impossible on a finite planet, and that curbing gross domestic product is the only reliable method to avert ecological collapse. [3] Critics, however, maintain that technological innovation and the decoupling of resource use from economic growth can allow for sustainable expansion without sacrificing living standards. [4] While both sides present compelling ecological data, the degrowth movement's proposed solutions ultimately fail because they severely underestimate the political and social instability that would inevitably result from a deliberately induced global economic contraction. [5] Implementing degrowth policies would require a massive redistribution of wealth and an unprecedented level of international cooperation, neither of which is politically feasible in the current geopolitical climate. [6] Furthermore, a forced reduction in economic output would disproportionately harm developing nations, which rely on sustained growth to lift their populations out of poverty and build essential infrastructure.

Which sentence (provide the number from 1 to 6) contains the explicit main point of the passage?

Answer: 4 / Sentence 4 / Four / sentence 4 / four

Answer

Sentence 4
Sentence 4 is the correct answer because it explicitly states the author's central argument: that despite compelling ecological data, degrowth solutions fail due to their severe underestimation of resulting political and social instability. The preceding sentences set up a debate, while the subsequent sentences provide supporting evidence for this specific claim.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the structural function of the opening sentences.
Sentences 1 through 3 introduce a debate, presenting the viewpoints of degrowth advocates and their critics without expressing the author's own stance.
Differentiating attributed viewpoints from the author's own voice is essential for locating the main point.
2
Locate the sentence where the author asserts their own overarching conclusion.
In Sentence 4, the author transitions from summarizing others to stating their own thesis: that the degrowth movement's solutions 'ultimately fail' due to the underestimation of political and social instability.
The explicit main point must be the central claim that the author seeks to prove.
3
Verify that the remaining sentences act as supporting premises for this claim.
Sentences 5 and 6 provide specific examples of the instability and impracticality mentioned in Sentence 4 (political unfeasibility and harm to developing nations).
A true main point is supported by the evidence and subsidiary points in the rest of the passage.

Key Concept

Explicit Main Point Identification
Rate this question