Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardPoints of Disagreement

Passage A
The Late Bronze Age Mediterranean was characterized by a highly integrated, specialized international economy. While many historians point to external shocks, such as droughts or invasions, as the definitive catalysts for the era's collapse, the root cause was internal. The hyper-specialization of these states made them structurally brittle. Their rigid administrative systems and heavy reliance on imported goods meant that a disruption in any single node—such as a localized famine or a regional conflict—inevitably cascaded across the network, leading to systemic failure. Thus, external shocks merely exposed a structural inevitability; the economic architecture of the system dictated that it was destined to fracture under its own weight.

Passage B
The tendency to view the Late Bronze Age collapse as an inevitable consequence of systemic economic fragility ignores the resilience these societies had demonstrated for centuries. The interconnected trade networks, rather than being inherently brittle, actually provided a robust buffer against localized failures by allowing resources to be dynamically redirected to struggling regions. What precipitated the catastrophic collapse was not a structural flaw waiting to be exposed by a minor disruption, but rather an unprecedented, century-long megadrought that decimated agricultural yields across the entire Mediterranean basin. No economic system, regardless of its internal structure, could have withstood such a profound and widespread environmental shock.

Based on the passages, the authors would be most likely to disagree over which of the following?

  1. A
    Whether an economic system with less specialization could have successfully withstood the century-long megadrought.
  2. The impact of interconnected trade networks on the vulnerability of Late Bronze Age societies to localized disruptions.Answer
  3. C
    Whether external environmental factors played a contributing role in the collapse of the Late Bronze Age societies.
  4. D
    Whether the hyper-specialization of the Late Bronze Age economy was unprecedented compared to earlier historical eras.
  5. E
    Whether the rigid administrative systems of the Late Bronze Age were the primary cause of the region's localized famines.

Answer

The authors disagree on the impact of interconnected trade networks on the vulnerability of Late Bronze Age societies to localized disruptions.
The correct answer accurately identifies a central conflict between the two texts. Passage A claims that the interconnected trade networks and reliance on imported goods made the societies structurally brittle, meaning that a 'disruption in any single node—such as a localized famine... inevitably cascaded across the network.' Thus, economic integration increased vulnerability to localized disruptions. In direct contrast, Passage B argues that these interconnected networks 'actually provided a robust buffer against localized failures by allowing resources to be dynamically redirected.' Therefore, the authors directly disagree on whether economic integration mitigated or exacerbated the impact of localized disruptions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Passage A to determine the author's view on the Late Bronze Age trade networks.
Passage A argues that hyper-specialization and interconnected trade made the societies structurally brittle, causing minor localized disruptions to inevitably cascade into systemic failure.
Identifying the first author's core premise is necessary to establish one side of the potential disagreement.
2
Analyze Passage B to determine the author's view on the same trade networks.
Passage B contends that the interconnected trade networks provided a robust buffer against localized failures by dynamically redirecting resources.
Identifying the second author's core premise allows for a direct comparison with Passage A.
3
Compare the two views to isolate a specific point of mutual disagreement.
Passage A views the trade networks as exacerbating vulnerability to localized disruptions, whereas Passage B views them as mitigating vulnerability to localized disruptions.
A correct point of disagreement must be a proposition that one author clearly affirms and the other clearly denies.
4
Evaluate the answer choices against the identified disagreement.
The option regarding the impact of interconnected trade networks on vulnerability to localized disruptions perfectly captures this conflicting perspective.
This confirms the correct answer choice while ensuring distractors are based on false disagreements or unsupported claims.

Key Concept

Identifying strict points of disagreement by analyzing how two authors characterize the exact same historical mechanism.
Rate this question

Topics

Points of Disagreement

More questions from this topic