Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyApplying the Negation Technique

In Logical Reasoning, the Negation Technique is used to test whether an assumption is truly necessary for an argument to hold. This technique requires accurately forming the logical negation of a candidate assumption statement. Match each assumption statement below with its exact logical negation.

  • All successful entrepreneurs are risk-takers.At least one successful entrepreneur is not a risk-taker.
  • Some new tax policies are beneficial.No new tax policies are beneficial.
  • No seasoned investors ignore market trends.At least one seasoned investor ignores market trends.
  • If the interest rate rises, inflation will decrease.The interest rate rises, and inflation does not decrease.

Answer

The correct pairings are: 'All...' negates to 'At least one... is not...'; 'Some...' negates to 'No...'; 'No...' negates to 'At least one... is...'; and 'If A, then B' negates to 'A happens and B does not'.
Each assumption statement has been paired with its exact logical contradictory. A mathematically sound negation covers all remaining logical possibilities without going too far. For example, the negation of an 'all' claim simply requires one counterexample, and the negation of a conditional claim shows the sufficient condition occurring without the necessary condition.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the quantifier or logical structure in the first statement: 'All successful entrepreneurs...'
It is a universal affirmative. The exact logical negation is 'Not all' or 'At least one is not'. Match with 'At least one successful entrepreneur is not a risk-taker.'
Negating 'All' does not mean 'None'; it merely requires a single counterexample to make the original statement false.
2
Identify the quantifier in the second statement: 'Some new tax policies...'
It is an existential affirmative. The exact logical negation is 'None'. Match with 'No new tax policies are beneficial.'
If it is false that 'some' (at least one) policy is beneficial, then zero policies are beneficial.
3
Identify the quantifier in the third statement: 'No seasoned investors...'
It is a universal negative. The exact logical negation is 'Some' or 'At least one'. Match with 'At least one seasoned investor ignores market trends.'
If it is false that 'no one' does something, it must mean that at least one person does it.
4
Identify the logical structure of the fourth statement: 'If the interest rate rises...'
It is a conditional statement. The exact logical negation is that the trigger happens but the result does not. Match with 'The interest rate rises, and inflation does not decrease.'
A conditional statement is only violated when the sufficient condition (the 'if' clause) is met, but the necessary condition (the 'then' clause) fails to occur.

Key Concept

Logical negation involves producing a statement that must be false when the original is true, and must be true when the original is false, without overreaching.
Rate this question

Topics

Applying the Negation Technique

More questions from this topic