Safety Inspector: The factory management claims that they prioritize a culture of safety above all else. Yet, their recent decision to aggressively expand into volatile international markets is widely considered by industry analysts to be a highly risky move. Therefore, the management's claim regarding their prioritization is clearly false.
Statement: The safety inspector's argument is logically flawed because it relies on shifting the meaning of a key concept during the course of the reasoning.
Answer: Answer
Answer
True
The safety inspector's argument commits a classic fallacy of equivocation. It takes the management's stated commitment to a 'culture of safety' (implying workplace and physical safety) and attempts to disprove it by citing a 'highly risky' financial and strategic business expansion. Financial risk and physical safety are distinct concepts. By treating them as opposites in the same context, the argument impermissibly shifts the meaning of the concept, making the given statement true.
Step-by-Step Solution
Key Concept
Flaw in the Reasoning: Equivocation