Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardCannot Be True Questions

According to the latest archaeological report from the Kaelen Valley excavation: Any ceramic artifact found in Stratum C that exhibits cobalt glazing must have been fired at temperatures exceeding 1000 degrees Celsius. However, extensive structural analysis confirms that no kiln located in the valley's Northern Settlement was capable of sustaining temperatures above 1000 degrees Celsius. Furthermore, all discovered artifacts featuring the 'Crescent Moon' motif were produced exclusively in the kilns of the Northern Settlement and all of them exhibit cobalt glazing.

Statement: Based strictly on the rules provided in the archaeological report, it is logically possible for a ceramic artifact featuring the 'Crescent Moon' motif to have been discovered in Stratum C.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is False, as it describes a logically impossible scenario that directly contradicts the provided deductive chain.
The correct answer is False because the statement claims a scenario is logically possible when the premises strictly prohibit it. A Crescent Moon artifact is necessarily fired in a Northern Settlement kiln (meaning a maximum of 1000 degrees) and has cobalt glazing. According to the first rule, any cobalt-glazed item in Stratum C must be fired above 1000 degrees. Because a single artifact cannot fulfill both conflicting temperature conditions, it physically cannot be found in Stratum C.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Map the conditional rules regarding Stratum C and temperature.
Artifact found in Stratum C AND exhibits cobalt glazing → Fired > 1000 degrees Celsius.
To establish the baseline requirements for the hypothetical scenario presented in the statement.
2
Map the properties of Crescent Moon artifacts based on the premises.
Crescent Moon motif → Fired in Northern Settlement kilns AND exhibits cobalt glazing.
To explicitly identify the inherent traits of the subject being evaluated.
3
Determine the temperature constraints of the Northern Settlement kilns.
Fired in Northern Settlement kilns → NOT Fired > 1000 degrees Celsius (Max 1000 degrees).
To link the production origin of the artifact to the overarching temperature rules.
4
Synthesize the rules to test the possibility of a Crescent Moon artifact existing in Stratum C.
Placing it in Stratum C triggers the requirement of being fired > 1000 degrees (due to its cobalt glazing). However, its origin in Northern kilns restricts it to ≤ 1000 degrees. This is a direct contradiction, meaning the placement is logically impossible.
To prove via modus tollens that the statement violates the established parameters and therefore cannot be true.

Key Concept

Cannot Be True Questions
Rate this question

Topics

Cannot Be True Questions

More questions from this topic