Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPrimary Purpose in Multi-Viewpoint Passages

Consider the following passage regarding linguistic attrition:

Scholars of linguistics have continuously disputed the foundational causes of language extinction. The orthodox paradigm suggests that language shift is propelled by economic pragmatism; minority populations willingly forsake their native dialects to integrate into a dominant socioeconomic class. Under this paradigm, linguistic homogenization is viewed as the unavoidable corollary of global market integration.

In recent years, a revisionist faction of sociolinguists has rejected this pragmatic explanation, asserting that it masks the coercive governmental mechanisms used to suppress minority languages. This faction highlights how educational mandates and jurisprudential frameworks are deployed to disenfranchise indigenous tongues, thereby transforming assimilation from an economic choice into an institutional mandate.

Although these revisionists successfully illuminate the institutional pressures ignored by the orthodox paradigm, their approach theoretically overdetermines the efficacy of state control. By depicting linguistic minorities purely as passive subjects of governmental coercion, the revisionists inadvertently erase the agency of these speakers. Resolving this debate requires an analytical framework that acknowledges the severe structural limitations imposed by institutions, while simultaneously recognizing the deliberate, tactical adaptations speakers employ to navigate those strictures.

Based on the text above, arrange the following rhetorical actions in the sequence the author uses to construct the passage's primary argument.

  1. 1Outlining an established theoretical paradigm that explains a sociological phenomenon in terms of practical utility.
  2. 2Introducing a revisionist faction that challenges the established paradigm by focusing on institutional pressures.
  3. 3Critiquing the revisionist faction for inadvertently diminishing the autonomy of the subjects it studies.
  4. 4Proposing an integrated analytical framework that accounts for both structural limitations and subject agency.

Answer

The correct rhetorical sequence is: 1) Outlining an established theoretical paradigm, 2) Introducing a revisionist faction, 3) Critiquing the revisionist faction, 4) Proposing an integrated analytical framework.
The passage is carefully structured as a dialectic. It begins with a thesis (the orthodox paradigm regarding economic pragmatism), introduces an antithesis (the revisionist perspective regarding institutional coercion), highlights a flaw in the antithesis, and finally arrives at a synthesis (an integrated framework acknowledging both systemic structure and individual agency).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the function of the first paragraph.
The author presents the orthodox paradigm based on economic pragmatism.
This establishes the conventional baseline understanding of the topic, which serves as a foundation for the ensuing debate.
2
Determine the function of the second paragraph.
The author introduces a revisionist faction that argues against the orthodox view by highlighting state coercion.
This introduces the primary conflict in the passage, contrasting the initial viewpoint with a fundamentally different institutional perspective.
3
Examine the shift at the beginning of the final paragraph.
The author concedes a strong point of the revisionist view but then exposes its primary theoretical flaw: the erasure of speaker agency.
The author must demonstrate why neither existing perspective is fully adequate before offering their own solution.
4
Identify the ultimate conclusion and rhetorical destination.
The author proposes a new framework synthesizing elements from both views (acknowledging both structural limitations and tactical adaptations).
This final move reveals the author's primary purpose for writing the passage: to resolve the theoretical deadlock through synthesis.

Key Concept

Authorial Progression and Rhetorical Purpose
Estimated Time:2m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Primary Purpose in Multi-Viewpoint Passages

More questions from this topic